Images

PTI MNA Iqbal Afridi needs to remember he has a job, and it’s not policing women’s clothes

PTI MNA Iqbal Afridi needs to remember he has a job, and it’s not policing women’s clothes

We wish the parliamentarian would concern himself with the people's problems as much as he concerned himself with a senior K-Electric official's clothes.
Updated 16 Aug, 2024

If you’re living in Pakistan, you’ve probably complained about your exorbitant electricity bill some time in the past couple of months. No one can escape it, not the rich, not the poor, no one. This is something Pakistanis should be concerned about. PTI MNA Muhammad Iqbal Khan Afridi is instead concerned about what a female representative of K-Electric was wearing to a National Assembly committee meeting on power.

The representative for NA-27 Khyber made a ridiculous statement about a K-Electric official after a meeting of the Standing Committee on Power to which the distribution company was invited to brief the committee on power generation and load-shedding.

According to Geo News, Afridi waited for the K-Electric team to leave the room before calling the woman’s clothes inappropriate and declaring there should be an SOP for clothing when attending a standing committee meeting.

The Geo News reporter noted that there was a consensus among the members of the standing committee — of which Afridi is not a member — that the woman’s clothes were appropriate and ‘sober’. The chairman of the committee, Muhammad Idrees of the PML-N, told Geo TV that it was inappropriate to speak about her clothes and apologised for the incident.

After the committee meeting, Afridi spoke to the media outside where he said people look to the assembly as an example to follow. Inexplicably, he said the K-Electric representative’s appearance would also be looked at as an example to be followed and he feared that if people were to dress like this “in a respectable society, what would children have to say about it”.

He described the woman’s clothes as a “sign of the system, society and establishment’s decline” and said in a society where his brothers, sisters and daughters lived, it was “not okay” for people like that to enter society.

We could write a thesis on how this man needs to keep his unsolicited, ignorant opinions to himself and perhaps sequester himself at home, where there is no risk of him seeing the female gender save for those related to him, but we’ve written all that before. We’re written article after article about how Pakistani men need to leave Pakistani women alone, but they don’t do much good because the Pakistani men who feel the need to speak about people’s clothes don’t have the good sense to keep quiet.

Men like Afridi will be told they are wrong and then go speak to the media outside, expanding on their stupidity and pat themselves on the back for a job well done, forgetting that they have actual jobs that don’t involve them policing women’s clothes. It is frightening to know that at a time when Pakistanis quite literally don’t know what to do about their electricity bills, when people are being driven to suicide because they do not know how they are going to pay these exorbitant bills, our representatives, the ones whose salaries come from our tax money, are thinking of women’s clothes instead of our problems.

The woman whose clothes Afridi found so offensive is a professional with years of experience. She has worked her way to the top and most certainly earned her spot at the table, yet her years of accomplishments and effort were reduced in an instant to a single outfit. She was there to discuss one of the most heated issues in our country at the moment, but there was more focus on what she was wearing.

We don’t care what the K-Electric representative was wearing. It is none of our business what she was wearing. It is none of Afridi’s business what she was wearing. And we won’t dignify these misogynistic remarks with a description of what she was wearing. We want to know what she was saying. What were her and her team’s justifications for electricity bills that have doubled and tripled in a few months? What did they have to say about load-shedding in Pakistan’s biggest city? What did they say about electricity tariffs?

Afridi seemed quite concerned with a ‘respectable society’ and what the children will say, but we care more about how the children and the rest of the citizens of Pakistan will pay their electricity bills. And in a respectable society, men should do better than zooming in on what a woman is wearing.

And if he thinks people look to the National Assembly as a pillar of respectability and decorum or a fashion advice column, he really should — as the unrestrained youth put it — touch grass. People have so much more to care about that a woman’s clothes — they are being forced to choose between basic necessities and paying electricity bills. They don’t think that highly of politicians and they certainly don’t look to them as icons of fashion or respectability. Those days are long gone. Now, we simply hope our representatives won’t embarrass us but it seems even that is too big an ask.

The other members of the committee described her clothes as ‘sober’ but clearly Afridi couldn’t get past his moral outrage to concentrate on why he was at the committee meeting in the first place — to question the power distributor on its practices.

Afridi seems to have been concerned about the message her clothes sent to the people of Pakistan, but his words sent an even more damning message to the women of Pakistan — no matter how you rise, there will always be a man there to belittle you because of their own insecurities, and they could use everything from your clothes to your makeup to your demeanour to your tone. Perhaps that’s the message men like Afridi want to send in the first place. Thankfully, the women of Pakistan don’t give a damn.

Comments

Khalid Masud Aug 16, 2024 06:24pm
Sad .- a typical Pakistani make - a misogynist with no brain.
Recommend
Ehsan Aug 16, 2024 06:31pm
Mental disorder
Recommend
Usama Aug 16, 2024 06:43pm
And you also has a job which is just to report the incident not to put your views on that MR writer
Recommend
Ishrat Hyatt Aug 16, 2024 06:47pm
Three cheers for this expression of disgust - will share in all my social media platforms as well as send by mail! I hope he gets to read it too - if he is educated enough though he sounds like an ignorant slob.
Recommend
DBFBHR Aug 16, 2024 07:04pm
Excellent article. Mr Afridi needs to be counseled.
Recommend
Shoaib Aug 16, 2024 07:13pm
If Mr. Afridi was not comfortable with the dress of k -electric employee it's normal plz don't make an issue. We all should dress decently and according to what our religion tells and not the west which our so called intellectual class is following .
Recommend
Ehsan Aug 16, 2024 07:29pm
What was he focused on, Taliban in waiting?
Recommend
yo! Aug 16, 2024 08:09pm
we know that most MNAs are "liars", so when they say the lady wears "sober" it means they are lying through their teeth :-D
Recommend
Ahmed Aug 16, 2024 08:13pm
He isn't concerned about that. He saw something wrong and called it out. Kinda like what you people are doing. Why do you people call out all wrong whenever someone talks against vulgarity? Why not say the same when someone condemns trafficking or corruption.
Recommend
Jamil Soomro Aug 16, 2024 09:08pm
Here comes another bogus man( No.4) after Adnan Siddiqui, Sahil Adeem, Khalilur Rehman Qamar and now Iqbal Afridi. All of them have one thing in common which they profess the degrading of women. It appears there is no shortage of bogus men in Pakistan.?
Recommend
Dr Aamir Aug 16, 2024 09:11pm
I am curious to know what that women was wearing.
Recommend
Jawaid kamal Aug 16, 2024 09:32pm
Whole Pakistan is tilting in that direction, unfortunately.
Recommend
Say No to Dynasty politics Aug 16, 2024 10:08pm
The problem here is with his eyes. Afridi needs to move to Afghanistan where he will be much happier and so will we.
Recommend
Aman Aug 16, 2024 10:11pm
Bravo! why can't these men just keep their mouths shut about women's clothes?! MINDING their own business could save them a lot of time. But how will they garner political support
Recommend
XYZ Aug 17, 2024 12:10am
@usama It's an opinion piece... or can you not read?
Recommend
Abdul Bari Aug 17, 2024 12:27am
I don't understand why the people like you don't have brain in their skulls or the guts needed to critically analyze something. Firstly, nature created women with integrated shyness and dignity way more than men. She is created with such a shyful nature that she hides her beauty from all mankind except few. It's just like a precious diamond that is safely and secured and protected from the eyes and hands of masses. It's not the nature of women to become apple of everyone eyes but rather to conceal herself from the outside world. But if she stangel her nature and shows her adorment and beautified herself in front of everyone then it's inevitable in nature that when you break it's laws, it's give birth to corruption in the society. This lady who was bluntly and openly breaking and destroying the nature by wearing extremely immoral clothes, is responsible for spreading moral corruption in land and they must to stop even by enforcing strict laws.
Recommend
sam Aug 17, 2024 03:25am
@XYZ you are such an obnoxious person. Condescending. Look at the way you talk. No civility at all.
Recommend
Najma Hisham Aug 17, 2024 04:49am
He seems to have a perverted mind. Instead of focusing on the job he kept salivating on the ladies appearance.
Recommend
Alam Aug 17, 2024 05:41am
Iqbal Afridi is right. Those people should be a role model for the society.
Recommend
Mo Aug 17, 2024 06:13am
Great Thinker!!!
Recommend
Ameer Hamzah Aug 17, 2024 09:12am
can anyone dare to write this 'opinionated news' in Urdu?
Recommend
the Innovator Aug 17, 2024 09:20am
Thumbs up to the Parliamentarian! We are with you !!. When you see an immoral act happening, stop it, stop with your hands or words, dont be afraid of what people say! Just follow your way!!!!
Recommend
rabia Aug 17, 2024 09:20am
I don't think our people know the very basics of what their jobs entail, and what they can/should do in that capacity. NO ONE has a right to harass anyone this way. But hey this is Pakistan, one of the most misogynist societies in the world. I grew up putting up with it, and it has never stopped.
Recommend
Commenter84633 Aug 17, 2024 11:07am
@ Abdul Bari LOL what kind of drugs are you on? Do you live in the medieval ages?
Recommend
Commenter84633 Aug 17, 2024 11:09am
@Alam K-Electric employees should be role models?
Recommend
Hammad Aug 17, 2024 11:21am
If only he had cared to lower his gaze as commanded by the religion he follows, he would have saved himself from the so-called annoyance and rage he was seen spewing out afterwards
Recommend
KHAN wang Aug 17, 2024 11:26am
What is the value of this kind of parliamentarian? What help will he bring to Pakistan?
Recommend
Shabbir Aug 17, 2024 11:42am
Committees should consist of professional people ideally, however, if these people are not available with parties, then they should be properly trained/briefed on the issues before meeting, so that they remain focused on core issues.
Recommend
Shala Aug 17, 2024 12:11pm
True Afridi should mind his business, but the so called fashion and looking so called modern has gone too far too. Since when is being malnourished and wearing clothes like a homeless person short and see through Pakistani culture?
Recommend
Anonymous Aug 17, 2024 12:38pm
I mean at least put the author name so we know who is giving the opinion.
Recommend
Parbat Aug 17, 2024 01:50pm
Totally biased, one sided view. A good article takes/ debates both side of an issue Did Afridi object to lady’s capabilities? Apparently no We have a religion and culture which doesn’t inhibit women progress but does tell men and women to dress modestly behave in a civic manner
Recommend
Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad Aug 17, 2024 02:35pm
Can someone elaborate upon what actually she was wearing please?
Recommend
Commenter84633 Aug 17, 2024 03:08pm
@Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad Pretty sure I saw a Twitter post where it was a blue kameez with three quarter sleeves. just wasn't wearing a dupatta.
Recommend
JohnDoe Aug 17, 2024 03:38pm
Then why most Pakistanis are dying to get to the West!!
Recommend
ady Aug 17, 2024 03:44pm
@Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad, that's the question. Everyone has a difference tolerance of these aspects.. ranging from "even the eyes shouldn't be visible" to "whatever the case maybe, don't be shocked". So what Afridi is saying isn't clear, i.e. what is or isn't appropriate? Can't just leave it to "common sense" now can we? Not wearing dupatta triggers someone, while wearing dupatta isn't enough either for someone else. There is no defined dress code like they have in KSA e.g. so complaining out of the blue isn't exactly making much sense. Have the law passed, then Mr. Afridi has a point when someone oversteps. But we know this is not happening, not in this day and age.
Recommend
Mujaddid Aug 17, 2024 04:00pm
It is a freedom of her choice but there cannot be coercion on the women about their dress.
Recommend
John Malik Aug 17, 2024 06:05pm
Is he Taliban’s fashion consultant? Never heard of this person before.
Recommend
Ram Aug 17, 2024 06:26pm
Diverting focus from main issue nation is facing (electricity bills) to women outfit. Unfortunate.
Recommend
Raza Aug 17, 2024 06:59pm
All should follow formal dress code as is the norm. Anything else just shows how corrupted a mindset is of an individual. You can dress however you like but in professional setting, a certain requirement should be set.
Recommend
Ahmed Aug 17, 2024 07:07pm
@Mujadid Should nudity be allowed in public? If no then that will be coercion If yes then your worldview is different from ours.
Recommend
Toni Shah Aug 17, 2024 07:46pm
Someone commented that the writer's job is to just to report the incident and not give their views; however, I want to point out that they are wrong. This is an opinion piece as it is in the Comment section of the paper. It is appropriate for the writer to give their opinion. I thought the column was very well written and succint.
Recommend
Toni Shah Aug 17, 2024 07:47pm
I can't roll my eyes hard enough.
Recommend
Palvasha von Hassell Aug 17, 2024 08:04pm
Maybe he thinks this is Afghanistan under the Taliban?!
Recommend
rida Aug 17, 2024 09:13pm
whoever wrote this article needs a raise cuz lmao, this was written in such a respectable manner and yet dissed him (afridi) so good.
Recommend
I A KHAN Aug 17, 2024 10:40pm
it is not clear what she was wearing but there is no doubt Pakistani women are more revealing when I see the TV anchor in National annual function attended by president and other dignitaries. simply socking. Pakistani society has become too foward to see it. Few years ago MolanaTariq Jameel criticised it and described it as the cause of repeated National disasters and the whole Nation and news papers rose against him and he was forced to apologise
Recommend
I A KHAN Aug 17, 2024 10:42pm
It is not a misogony but rapidly declining modesty and Haya in the society
Recommend
Multani Aug 17, 2024 10:48pm
Agreed 100%, vulgarity is not acceptable in our society, women have to be in their limits set by us, we are not a shameless western culture.
Recommend
Imran Quraishi Aug 18, 2024 02:31am
His face says it all. PTI should get rid of this evil minded man before he shatters the already crumbling image of PTI in the public eye.
Recommend
Sheraz Aug 18, 2024 02:38am
And you're job is not to impose your opinion. He is backed by Pakistani people and that gave him authority to point out ill-mannered dress-code or language BUT not you. You just report and leave the opinions to reader. Unfortunately Pakistani reporter and columnist are not professional at all.
Recommend
Kamran Aug 18, 2024 03:39am
Please don't mix one issue with another issue.all men and women must be appropriate in their demeanour and attire.women must be respectful and ever tend to flaunt their flesh.people on the top of achelon must not borrow culture from west as they borrow dlar.pardonly,your values don't represent majority women that are sober and gentle in their ways.afridi reflects the values of majority women and culture
Recommend
Kamran Aug 18, 2024 03:41am
I see,your views don't reflect culture of majority of women of Pakistan.wheras Afridi does.women are more than piece or lump of a flash.a women with naked and silly dress surely not represents majority of our women.they are western cultural aliens.
Recommend
Polaris Aug 18, 2024 05:10am
The K-Electric must have a dress code for a person representing them.
Recommend
Fida Hussain Aug 18, 2024 07:26am
In the first place, it seems like I am reading some misandrist. Your words are most like imposing rather than expressing. I have seen many women who condemn fellow women for wearing veil/burqa and maintaining their customs. Follow the same rule you have set for men! Period.
Recommend
Mustafa Nazir Ahmad Aug 18, 2024 09:10am
Apparently a show of solidarity with a parliamentarian based on his political affiliation irrespective of the fact that the person in question is being castigated by his colleagues including the ones belonging to his political party.
Recommend
KBC Aug 18, 2024 09:12am
I never see this long articles, but I can understand where it's coming from. I want to see the pictures of that lady at this mean day/occasion. Can Media show the pictures, rather than remembering Mr. Afridi of their job?
Recommend
KBC Aug 18, 2024 09:13am
Please first share the pictures of the last, rather than doing your story telling by words.
Recommend
Mustafa Nazir Ahmad Aug 18, 2024 09:20am
Expecting civility in response to Usama's comment is like expecting Imran Khan to refrain from taking U-turns and like expecting the PTI's supporters to face the reality rather than dodging it for which they have become notorious.
Recommend
IMRAN AHMED Aug 18, 2024 11:35am
This widespread mental aberration: misogyny based on an assumption that men have an innate right to control women's sexuality is widespread in a few uncivilised societies. Vigorous, high profile enforcement of gender rights, condemnation & ridicule of chauvinism by celebrities coupled with education via information media & school syllabi may help improve matters.
Recommend
Ali Aug 18, 2024 03:42pm
Well penned
Recommend
Imtiaz Baloch Aug 18, 2024 04:33pm
This is the rationale of the Taliban's to keep the woman out and Mr. Afridi was describing his outrage on the same lines. Our urban space is being challenged and shrinking rather quickly.
Recommend
Rahil Aug 18, 2024 05:40pm
Take a hike and hide in your own stupidity and backwardness!
Recommend