Images

Ali Gul Pir believes we have bigger problems than Barzakh

Ali Gul Pir believes we have bigger problems than Barzakh

The rapper-comedian has something to say about the controversy surrounding the Indian show featuring Pakistani actors.
07 Aug, 2024

Barzakh has come to an end but the drama surrounding it isn’t dying out, even after Zindagi announced that the show would be taken down from YouTube in Pakistan in light of a controversy over its ‘inappropriate’ content.

Just after Zindagi’s announcement to pull the show from YouTube on August 9, designer Maria B took to her social media and threatened to take team Barzakh to court for promoting what she called ‘provocative’ themes.

In response, rapper Ali Gul Pir pointed out that Barzakh was an Indian production and asked whether the designer would pursue similar legal action against other international shows like Game of Thrones, which depicts controversial content such as incest.

While highlighting the selective outrage directed towards shows featuring Pakistani actors, Gul Pir, on his Instagram stories, said he genuinely believes we have bigger problems at hand — such as lack of education and inflation.

“The problem is that there are many things on the internet, on YouTube. We have faced the same problem before. For three years, we faced a YouTube ban. This [Barzakh] is an Indian product. Your actors have acted in it but it’s an international project. You cannot ban everything that is there on the internet,” he said emphatically.

Gul Pir said that banning anything is counterproductive because it makes that thing more popular. Instead, one can simply not watch what they don’t want to watch. “You don’t have to watch these things. I didn’t even know about this drama until you made it famous. I didn’t even know it existed. There are so many actors who, if you don’t like [them], don’t watch their stuff. But you cannot ban everything, that is not the solution.”

The rapper added that all the rage Pakistanis feel is often misdirected with no one ever criticising the state of government hospitals or the lack of infrastructure and education.

“Unfortunately, we are here and the world has progressed. What we did at the Olympics, no outrage. What our country is going through, no outrage. Drama? Court! The whole country will go to court over a drama. There is no outrage over lack of education, and there was no outrage over the condition of Jinnah Hospital but where sex is involved, outrage!”

On Tuesday, after Zindagi announced that it would be taking down Barzakh from YouTube Pakistan on August 9, the show’s director, Asim Abbasi, said he supports the decision because he does not believe in jeopardising the safety of his team.

Taking to X, he tweeted, “No story of mine is worth more than the safety of all the beautiful, talented artists who came together to craft it. So this decision really is for the best. For all those who have showered us with love, I hope you enjoy the finale! And remember — stories never die.”

Barzakh, directed by Abbasi, known for his previous successes Churails and Cake, has accumulated millions of views on YouTube. The show features an ensemble cast including Fawad Khan, Sanam Saeed, M Fawad Khan, Salman Shahid, Khushhal Khan, Sajid Hasan, Uzma Beg, and Nighat Choudhry.

Comments

NYS Aug 07, 2024 03:18pm
Upsides and Downsides
Recommend
Ahmed Aug 07, 2024 03:33pm
We have many problems. Why do celebrities ask us to talk about them only when anyone speaks against vulgarity of any type. Why not talk about child malnutrition when taking about political corruption? Why not talk about poverty while talking about rising temperatures? Get the idea?
Recommend
Jawad Khan Aug 07, 2024 03:54pm
Yes, we already have much bigger problems to deal with, so we cannot tolerate any more foolish dramas like "BARZAKH."
Recommend
Taj Ahmad Aug 07, 2024 05:28pm
Social media expanding too fast with new technology and new smartphones and other devices coming out in the market too fast that we as parents not ready for it or to buy these new products for our children’s, please slow down in new technology and take it easy in life as well.
Recommend
Jamil Soomro Aug 07, 2024 05:53pm
What a totally illogical and bogus comment by Ali Gul Pir. All of a sudden he has remembered Jinnah Hospital,infrastructure and education on talking about the indecency of Barzakh. He should stick to his being Rapper-Comedian.?
Recommend
Dean Colloway Aug 07, 2024 06:41pm
Comparing Oranges with Apples Mr. Gul.
Recommend
Rehana Bounse Aug 07, 2024 09:22pm
You’re absolutely right . Do not overspend on elite players or teams . Spend on preventing child marriages to far older men . Improve education for All & special ed for males of the families regarding young girl & far older man getting married & then abusive relationships. The Men of the country Have To Be Educated on how to be Dads & Grand Dads . Our education system is way down . Rich send their kids abroad to get education. Hospitals for all, treatment for all with discounts & payment plans . Morality of the adult males & females have to be top notch
Recommend
amber Aug 07, 2024 09:33pm
LOL - agree
Recommend
Shareq Usman Aug 07, 2024 10:21pm
mashallah happy to see that my fellow Pakistan is realise that stopping disgusting vulgarity id important.This is such a bad argument.How is banning disgusting propaganda jeopardizing our efforts to develop proper infrastructure and better educational facilities
Recommend
AA Aug 07, 2024 10:39pm
A general comment on the topic. Yes we do have other problems and yes they are bigger, but this doesn't mean we sweep societal issues under the rug and allow them to penetrate deeper. USA is already dealing with this issue where significant portion of the population (the right wing) is advocating to limit influence of transexualism in kids. This didn't happen overnight, rather it spread over the last few decades and was allowed on the basis of inclusivity. We don't have to create shock value in order to be heard, strong stories sell.
Recommend
Dr Abdul Malik Aug 08, 2024 06:53am
@Jawad Khan: You don’t have to watch the “foolish dramas”. There are others who may not find it ‘foolish’. To each according to their taste. Take it easy, sir!
Recommend
Ravi Inder Aug 08, 2024 09:24am
Bro .... same in India ..
Recommend
Kamran Khan Aug 08, 2024 09:53am
Ali Gul Pir falls into the same category as Asim Abbasi, etc., and that's why he defended the show with lame logic. It is indeed an international show, just like any other international show. However, it is also a fact that almost all the actors in the show are from Pakistan, its director and writer are Pakistani, its co-producer is Pakistani, and it was filmed in Pakistan too. All these factors make this show a Pakistani show for the Pakistani audience. These are the reasons why many Pakistanis are upset with the show, not with any other foreign show as Ali Gul Pir has mentioned. I thank all Pakistanis, including Maria B, for standing against this type of anti-cultural show, which contradicts our moral ethics and our customs and traditions.
Recommend
asma sufi Aug 08, 2024 01:13pm
I was not planning to watch Barzakh because it seemed to be something out of a fairy-tale. So all the undue criticism forced me to see what could be objectionable to our pseudo pious audience. Voila! After watching the intro I found it to be a gripping story with spell binding photography and superb acting of all involved. The artistry and imagination is immensely engaging, hats off to Asif Abbasi. It will be taken off youtube in the near future is tragic. My only concern was the audio, which was discouraging. There are more pressing matters than a TV play. As rightly pointed out if it irks your sensibility for whatever deranged reason don't watch it!
Recommend
Laila Aug 12, 2024 04:27am
@ASMA SUFI So, the fake outrage made you watch the show? Interesting. I watched a few minutes of the first episode and while the visuals are beautiful, i thought it was a story about an old guy, who is now chasing his lost love and wants to marry her ghost. It was not my cup of tea. I only became aware it has homosexuality, postpartum depression, among others as topics through the criticism. I still won't watch it because it doesn't appeal to me. But I can appreciate the artistry of the experimental project. It is clear it was never meant fo Pakistani viewers. Otherwise it would have been launched on Pakistani tv network and not some Indian digital channel which the world can access. So for I don't get the outrage. Also it's interesting that we never show outrage when Pakistani channels through dramas consistently promote domestic violence, slapping women, forced marriages, deprivation of basic human rights and women rights while maintaining absolute silence on actual societal matters like the rampant violence against women in Pakistan in all its forms be that physical, sexual or emotional, child abuse, abuse of male boys bachabazi, the child abuse taking place at madarassas by socalled religious clerics, incest, hiv, child marriages, trafficking of children and women. The socalled outrage just created more viewers and publicity. So it backfired in a sense.
Recommend
Laila Aug 12, 2024 04:41am
For heavens sakes what on earth did he say that was so wrong? Whenever somebody points out our wrong/misguided priorities we starts whining and blame it on what aboutism, West, elites, liberal and what not. We are just not willing to confront our societys issues or resolve them. Our society is void of accountability or selfreflection or common sense.
Recommend