Images

Urwa and Mawra Hocane think you can eat your depression away

Urwa and Mawra Hocane think you can eat your depression away

"We keep hearing people have depression or some mental disease and it's all because of food, no other reason," said Urwa
Updated 07 Aug, 2019

When will our celebrities stop making ignorant statements about mental health?

The Hocane sisters, Mawra and Urwa appeared on Nida Yasir's morning show to promote their new clothing line, U X M and somehow the conversation shifted to talking about mental well-being.

In a clip that is now making rounds on social media, it's clear that they think depression is solely caused by your diet. Urwa went on to make a blanket statement: "There are so many problems these days, we hear someone say that they've got depression or mental 'disease', but its all because of food! There's no other reason."

“It’s what you put in your body", added Mawra, nodding in agreement.

It's about time celebrities educate themselves regarding mental health issues. Trivialising such an important issue is never okay. While we agree that eating a well-balanced diet is important and part of self-care, it is irresponsible to say it is the ONLY thing that causes mental illness or mood disorders like depression. Not to mention, sometimes it's just not in your control because not eating or not eating healthy is often even a symptom of depression.

Also, not everyone can afford to eat avocado ka halwa, if you know what we're talking about.

Mental illnesses are as real as physical ailments so we must make it acceptable for people to seek professional and medical help when they are going through a troubling time, instead of telling them to turn to things like religion, or food in this case. While that can help as a secondary support mechanism, it is dangerous to imply that those are treatments.

As confirmed by a Harvard Medical School study, there are several causes of depression that include faulty mood regulation by the brain, genetic vulnerability, stressful life events, or even side-effects of medication like birth control.

Mawra has since taken to her Instagram to defend the statement through a Google screenshot which reads: “If you eat lots of processed meat, fried food, refined cereals, candies, pastries, and high fats products, you are more likely to be anxious and depressed."

Well, looks like she completely missed the point. Even the screenshot doesn't state that food is the only reason for depression. Let's hope that our celebrities learn to admit their mistakes, recognise their own influence and privilege and make amends.

Comments

Saud Aug 07, 2019 03:35pm
Statements like these is what makes the discussion about depression a taboo. really .. really dumb.
Recommend
Samejo Aug 07, 2019 03:46pm
yes good suggestion. you also eat away cancer and HIV. this is some dum thing to say. well depression is part of life and we need actual support from family and friends. it cant be eaten away with healthy food.
Recommend
Aziz Aug 07, 2019 04:06pm
Wow! They really are genius!
Recommend
Abbas Aug 07, 2019 04:10pm
What is depression is bcoz of poverty and hunger.
Recommend
Salman Khan Aug 07, 2019 04:48pm
This is why celebrities should stay mum about things they don't understand. Misguiding people about medical conditions is a grave sin.
Recommend
Ahsan Gul Aug 07, 2019 07:44pm
These are actors and actress barely know about life. But since they are connected to the media people tend to follow and listen. Very injurious for them to suggest any medical remedies for the public.
Recommend
Waldo Aug 07, 2019 10:08pm
Ban all Morning shows, Problem solved.
Recommend
Nadeem Tabani Aug 07, 2019 11:42pm
She is absolutely wrong.
Recommend
Talha Aug 08, 2019 02:41am
I think what they probably meant to say was that diet plays a part in making people feel depressed and anxious rather than it being the sole reason...
Recommend
Tehseen Mazher Aug 08, 2019 03:20am
I do not agree that only the contributing factor in depression is diet there are other factors too that plays part like Heridity factors,unfortunate incidents like death in family, divorce , loss of job all these factors contribute too
Recommend
K R Aug 08, 2019 03:40am
Choice of food does not cause depression. Appetite is related , increased or decreased appetite can be a sign of depression. Relating food to depression the way these girls did shows their lack of information . People on tv hold power and can and influence common people like me . They should choose their words and opinion very carefully before sharing on these powerful platforms. Life is much more complicated then sayings like “Acha khaya karo khush raha karo”.
Recommend
Sameen Aug 08, 2019 05:46am
Nida Yasir show is already a nuisance and ignorant people like these sisters help in making these kind of programs more pathetic. The problem is instead of apologising and accepting that they have made a grave mistake by giving a wrong statement they are insisting that what they have said is correct.
Recommend
Raja Aug 08, 2019 05:50am
These sister are still trying to educate people by providing wrong screen shots from the internet. What an irony! They are not ready to accept their mistake, it reflects their haughty behaviour. Now they have made more difficult for those to get medical attention where families already treat depression as a normal thing which does not require treatment.
Recommend
What the Hocane Aug 08, 2019 07:19am
Marie Antoinette couldn’t have said it any better!
Recommend
CHITTARANJAN Aug 08, 2019 10:13am
Very irresponsible.
Recommend
Shahid Khan Aug 08, 2019 10:55am
There are billions of people on this planet and billion types of depression. So everyone whon is suffering from it might have different causes but will have same symptoms. Some people live all their lives in depression but not realising it, but some people are lucky enough to get help in the initial stages. Cure to this problem is varieties of things which exclude family support, exercise, personal hygiene having baths etc, and listening to others advice, and also diet as well . These are things that sounds easy to do for someone with healthy mind but it's a mountain to climb for a person who is struggling with depression. People who are helping those who are suffering from this disease should have patience and knowledge of all the above things to keep reminding the patient again and again until it's registered in their brain. Time is the cure for this.
Recommend
Jackal Aug 08, 2019 09:13pm
'Celebrity' sisters 'Hocane' are quite full of themselves. Can't believe this lot claims to be the moral voice of the nation.
Recommend
Saira Aug 11, 2019 10:29pm
Can someone please do the nation the service of banning Nida Yasir from live national tv. She is much too ignorant to deserve this kind of position and power.
Recommend