Images

Shaan Shahid has something to say about actors and depression, but he didn't get it right

Shaan Shahid has something to say about actors and depression, but he didn't get it right

Shaan should remember that mental illness is not a choice, and to characterise it as such causes more harm than good
Updated 02 Feb, 2019

A week ago, Mohsin Abbas Haider spoke up about going through depression and his fellows from the industry immediately reached out for support.

The Pakistani entertainment industry has not shied away from opening up about mental health issues and this incident reopened the conversation with celebs like Ali Gul Pir and Fia Khan speaking about their own hurdles with depression when urging Mohsin Abbas Haider to seek professional help.

Shaan Shahid recently shared his own opinions on the matter. However, his words were not specifically for Haider but rather the industry as a whole and its vulnerability to mental health issues.

Titling his thoughts, "Walking the thin line," Shaan went on to talk about the difficulties an actor faces due to the internalisation of a character's emotions when portraying them for the screen.

"For an actor/artist depression is a tool to achieve the state or the emotion to capture the essence of an expression. For example Van Gogh's pain can be seen on canvas... or for an actor who is living in a different character, for his eyes to look sad the artist has to feed depression to his mind so he /she can achieve the right expression.

From the post it seems like Shaan is speaking about inattentive method acting, where an actor, without much awareness about their psyche, tries to completely immerse themselves within their character by living as them behind the camera as well. Without proper care that can never be an easy thing to handle.

However, things took a turn for the worst when Shaan continued on and spoke of depression as an 'addiction' and a 'choice': "Unfortunately, actors and artists tend to cross the line and get addicted to, it the depression the pain. To stay with another character in your body is like fighting addiction. But there is a way out of this black hole."

Perhaps this is indeed directed towards Mohsin Abbas Haider, who played the terrifying criminal in Meri Gurya. To have to justify such acts to yourself in order to bring out the authenticity of a character can definitely be excruciating.

But what Shaan would do well to remember is that those suffering from mental health problems do not 'choose' to "cross the line" and remain in pain. To characterise mental illness as a choice and not a disease can adversely affect a person's healing process and actually prevent them from seeking help.

We're hoping that Shaan's post is more than a comment on the oblivious assumption that the entertainment industry is all about the glamour, because more and more are becoming aware about this. To know that such mental health problems are prevalent in the industry should mean the step is to make sure adequate support is present and mandated.

Comments

Ali Wadood Feb 02, 2019 10:02am
acting mean to reflect with complete control. when one loses focus its depression. control means control over every part of ones body and senses.
Recommend
asad Feb 02, 2019 11:03am
Shaan has got old, he should focus on characters of Uncle or father.
Recommend
Uzair Feb 02, 2019 12:07pm
That's called sadness, which is different from depression.
Recommend
Sameer Feb 02, 2019 03:26pm
I find Shan's retrospective refreshing!
Recommend
Khany Feb 02, 2019 03:26pm
Shaan is the best actors in Pakistans film industry which he didn't deserve. Pakistani film industry wasted Shaans talent due to its very low quality cheap budget movies. Yes today Pakistan film industry quality is no difference go Hollywood but it's too late for Shaan as age is catching up. He deserved 90s Bollywood. Most people are totally put off watching low quality Lollywood movies of the 90s.
Recommend
Ehsan Feb 02, 2019 07:37pm
I respect his opinion, very deep.
Recommend
YesDude Feb 02, 2019 09:55pm
Shan is one of the greatest actors Pakistan has. Unfortunately, the movie industry especially at his peak produced cheap movies. And the deplorable situation is that our standard has gone low, we think Humayun Saeed is a great actor and adore his movies.
Recommend
TarriQ Feb 02, 2019 11:02pm
When actors try to show their "intellectual" side in a way they expose their shortcomings!
Recommend
Usman Feb 03, 2019 05:45am
Shaan reminds me Robert Denero!!!
Recommend
Ahsan Gul Feb 03, 2019 09:42am
Shan is just an actor and not a psychologist so let us leave his comments right here.
Recommend