Images

Original animator of The Lion King calls the live-action remake cheap

Original animator of The Lion King calls the live-action remake cheap

“It’s sort of sad that the stockholder is now in the room deciding what movies get made," shared David Stephan
04 Aug, 2019

While Disney's live-action reboot of The Lion King has been roaring at the box office, critics and audiences have had mixed reviews.

The film also failed to impress one of the original animator's of the 1994 classic, David Stephan who called it "cheap".

In an interview with HuffPost, he said, “If you polled the crew of the original Lion King, most of them would say, ‘Why? Did you really have to do that?’ It kind of hurts.”

He added, “It’s sort of sad that the stockholder is now in the room deciding what movies get made. Disney’s now taken the cover off, and it’s now in your face: ‘Yeah, we just want to make money.’ That’s disappointing as an artist, from a studio that was founded on originality and art.”

Stephan also called the voice performances by the cast full of stars like Donald Grover and Beyonce "weak and wooden".

Dave Bossert, who did visuals for the classic also thought otherwise: “I love the fact that they kept James Earl Jones from the original as Mufasa. That was terrific. It’s a sort of homage to the original film. I thought the voice characterizations were terrific across the board. There wasn’t anything that struck me as being odd at all. I particularly liked John Oliver as Zazu and Seth Rogen as Pumbaa.”

Another animator, who worked on the original, Dave Bossert was a little more positive: “Visually, it’s stunning. In some instances, it’s a shot-by-shot version of the original animated film, and that didn’t bother me at all because I think the filmmakers were staying faithful to the original property. The faithfulness to the original animated film certainly endears it to the audience, without question.”

Have you watched The Lion King remake yet? Tell us in the comments below.

Comments

M. Saeed Aug 04, 2019 02:59pm
Remakes are only the testimony of the greatness of the original. Have we not seen the remakes of the old film Devdas? Do they not create a strong will to dig the archives and see the real original?
Recommend
Madeeha Nasar Aug 04, 2019 03:10pm
Yeah,the lion king reboot failed to create the same impact on us.It lacks many important things a film needs to have.I totally agree with David Stephan that some voiceovers were weak and this film was not upto the mark'The Lion King 'has set before.
Recommend
Atika Ahmed Aug 04, 2019 03:16pm
I watched it yesterday. As someone who grew up watching the original, I can understand why this one is being panned. Its not bad, but it is a lot more darker and more foreboding than the original.
Recommend
Rizwan Khalid Arain Aug 04, 2019 03:31pm
It was not up to the mark.
Recommend
Faizan Taqi Aug 04, 2019 04:24pm
A studio that was founded on originality and art? Did he really say that? Most disney movies are adaptations and reimaginations of old novels and books. And wasn't the lion king a blatant rip off of a japanese cartoon? So much so that they waited for the creator of the japanese cartoon die and then begin production on the lion king?
Recommend
Aban Usmani Aug 04, 2019 05:32pm
The new Lion King is fabulous. I watched the original one with my kids some 20 times 20 years ago. The visual effect of Live Lions moving the stampede all was very thrilling
Recommend
M Ayyaz Aug 04, 2019 05:44pm
My daughters loved the movie ...
Recommend
Ehsan Aug 04, 2019 07:46pm
Disney should not have made this copy.
Recommend
Ranger Aug 04, 2019 08:37pm
Waste of money. Was totally unnecessary.
Recommend
Martha Aug 04, 2019 11:33pm
I saw it last week. Don’t feel it was necessary...
Recommend
Chris Roberts Aug 05, 2019 01:15am
It may be that the entertainment industry has been running out of ideas. I've often wondered what purpose a remake of a film really serves when all too often the original version is far superior and can still be viewed.
Recommend
Jennifer McCloy Aug 05, 2019 03:25am
I've been to the movies to watch The Lion King twice. I loved it. It's fantastic they bought back James Earl Jones. I don't think any other could have done the voice of Mufasa justice. I had goosebumps and lump in my throat from the very beginning opening scene and song
Recommend
Zainab Aug 05, 2019 04:23am
My children loved it but I and my husband were really not impressed. A remake should be better than original otherwise it is a failure. If this would be the original film, I would be in awe but this is not and I was in awe before watching the original. The soundtrack, the light, the effects, I think everything was more cohesive in original. Yes, Pumbaa was definitely better in this one.
Recommend
Farid Yaqub Aug 05, 2019 04:38am
Watched Lion King On Saturday and really impressed by the effects and the feel of originality it gives...
Recommend
Abdul Samad Aug 05, 2019 05:19am
I disagree new Lion King is art of new technological era, we must look forward and forward and keep innovate the old traditions
Recommend
Miss Lauren Smith Aug 05, 2019 05:49am
I loved it the lion king live action
Recommend
NAQAD Aug 05, 2019 08:35am
"The film also failed to impress one of the original animator's of the 1994 classic, David Stephan who called it "cheap".'" David is right, other than high resolution graphics, there is not much to see in the move in terms of story, direction, editing, and creativity!
Recommend
dana a colonna Aug 06, 2019 11:40am
I loved the new Lion King and I also love The Old Lion King and I think the new one was fantastic it more tears to your eyes and parts of it and may you laugh and other parts of the movie and come on who doesn't love lions and tigers and only animals and especially comes to big cats everybody loves that Ivan Point myself to Disney Bradford Exchange Lion King clock and it plays Hakuna Matata every hour it's incredible I have it hanging in my kitchen and Hakuna Matata means no worries or every time you hear that makes you smile and the music's incredible I have it all on Spotify all 19 songs are done well and my cousin is a retired supervising artist Disney and I have a watercolor that one of the illustrators did for me of The Lion King and that is so precious to me when I look at that every day going in my living room
Recommend