Images

Sharmeen Obaid Chinoy hits back at Sonya Hussyn for her old comments about Mahira Khan

Sharmeen Obaid Chinoy hits back at Sonya Hussyn for her old comments about Mahira Khan

An old interview resurfaced in which Hussyn called Khan's character in her movie Raees a "sidekick".
Updated 30 Jun, 2021

Sharmeen Obaid Chinoy doesn't think actor Sonya Hussyn will ever be Mahira Khan and doesn't appreciate comments she made about her in the past.

Chinoy, the Oscar winning director, commented on an Instagram post by Grazia Pakistan.

In the post, the magazine had recirculated comments Hussyn made in a 2018 interview. She appeared on the After Moon Show hosted by Yasir Hussain on August 12, 2018.

Asim Azhar and Hussyn were the guests on the episode and in one segment, they were asked to answer a series of questions by quickly choosing from the options presented to them. One of the questions Hussyn was asked was if she were Mahira Khan, which film would she not do: Verna, Raees or Ho Mann Jahaan.

Hussyn chose Raees. "Why, because you don't want to work with Shah Rukh Khan?' asked the host.

"No, never," replied Hussyn. "It was never my dream to work with Shah Rukh Khan. My dream is that your character should be such that you are seen and you're not just a side character to a hero," she explained.

Chinoy didn't seem to like what she said and replied to the Grazia Pakistan post. "Don't think you'll ever be Mahirah Khan so you won't ever get to say no - don't diss other women in the industry, [it] reflects poorly on you and your upbringing," she wrote.

While Chinoy definitely has a point about pulling other women down, we wish our celebrities weren't asked questions like this on shows at all. They're often taken out of context and used to pit celebrities — most often women — against each other. Perhaps our celebrities also need to stop answering questions about the skills and choices of their fellow industry members.

Comments

Chrís Dăn Jun 30, 2021 12:47pm
A very sane advice by Chinoy.
Recommend
Funny man Jun 30, 2021 12:47pm
Are we out of issues which the west loves and have zero impact on the betterment of local women? That's why she is not busy making sub par films instead buttering local cinema queen.
Recommend
Rukhsana Jun 30, 2021 12:58pm
I this news worthy.
Recommend
Tariq Jun 30, 2021 01:05pm
Showbiz and controversy always goes side by side.
Recommend
Ahmad Gul Nazir Jun 30, 2021 01:06pm
In this whole discussion, writer has not discussed the demeaning nature of comments of Chinoy, nor did writer mention about the derogation it has shown to Sonya Hussain. Does she know what she is capable of and what type of roles she has been offered. I feet pity that our celebrities don't choose words with sanity. It's is as if Mahira khan has become a Holly cow whose work can't be ciriticsied and her poor choices can't be discussed.
Recommend
Riazullah Baig Jun 30, 2021 01:18pm
This lady has always been trying to belittle her own country and its people instead of helping overcome the shortcomings! Instead of building a school for girls in a remote area she would highlight the illiteracy amongst the female, but whatever she does is for her personal fame and publicity.
Recommend
truth Jun 30, 2021 01:24pm
Who is this Sonya n whats her line of work...anything worthy
Recommend
M. Saeed Jun 30, 2021 01:32pm
Why do we believe our screen-celebrities are intellectuals rivalling mega IQ brains?
Recommend
Umair Jun 30, 2021 01:33pm
what's the big deal in what sonia hussain said? Sharmeen obaid is making a mountain of molehill
Recommend
R Sher Jun 30, 2021 01:50pm
Isn't SOC doing just that, dissing another woman??
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 30, 2021 02:00pm
@Funny man there is NO west . Asian countries like Philipines,Japan,Malaysia,Indonesia,Turkey ,all citizens of these non european countries including China,Hong Kong,S.Korea,N.Korea wear pants shirts (men&women)and are a part of international community on reasonable pace. This West exists for you as Indonesia,Malaysia,Turkey not only make movies on all sensitive subjects but also their ladies represent countries in Miss Universe competetions. West and East live togather except Pakistanis.
Recommend
Dija Jun 30, 2021 02:23pm
Actually it reflects quite poorly on Sharmeen's upbringing !
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 30, 2021 02:55pm
@Riazullah Baig the lady has always been a pride for us because of her competetive winnings. Through showing the emotional &physical unfairness to poor people specifically women in Pakistan is a great service to humanity as the world is getting a fair idea how helpless are women in Pakistan& how unfairly they are treated. This world awareness would bring international pressure on Pak. Management about women rights aka Human Rights in which we have bottom recird. Already in assylums,Pakistani women are accepted immediately now and to this credit goes to Ms.Chinoy. Why you support unfairness with women in Pakistan?
Recommend
Shabia Jun 30, 2021 03:40pm
And what is wrong in what Sonia giving her personal opinion on the choice of roles? Who is Chinoy to berate her like that? Also why is Mahira treated as a goddess? As compared to Sonya's diverse roles and acting Mahira has nothing new to offer. Is there a trend nowadays to degrade senior and competent actors for Majora's sake when they are just giving answers to host's questions?
Recommend
Mustafa Jun 30, 2021 03:42pm
Well Ms. Chinoy don’t you think that everyone is entitled to have an opinion. Rather you castigate a woman’s child raising ability goes to show your own narrow mindedness and brings your own brought up in question. In my opinion Mahira Khan was nothing more than an eye candy in that “Bollywood” movie. The whole purpose of casting her was so the movie investors could amplify their return on investment by getting people across the border in the cinema because a Pakistani “star” was cast along a world superstar. Also Sonya Hussyn’s answer was based on the acting skills solely and not stardom. Being and actor and star are two separate things, few understand this.
Recommend
Sana Shahzad Malik Jun 30, 2021 04:14pm
Sonya was asked if she had been given choice? So she gave her opinion , what is the problem with Chinoy to bash her like that? Y do people have to suppress one to favour other? Seems like Chinoy has a lot of free time to answer the post of 2018?
Recommend
nadeya Jun 30, 2021 04:14pm
So what do you think is Ms chinoy doing here. She has treated hussyn the same way rather even worse. Two wrongs don't make one right. It could have done politely though.
Recommend
Riazullah Baig Jun 30, 2021 04:30pm
@Chrís Dăn I am not supporting the unequal treatment with women but believe in helping them actually. This Chenoy lady is finding fault but not the remedy.
Recommend
Abdul Moiz Jun 30, 2021 05:06pm
Our news these days
Recommend
Asad Jun 30, 2021 05:20pm
This is the fight of elite class / Feudal/ Establishment, and that does not represent 99.9% of Pakistan.
Recommend
Ehsan Jun 30, 2021 07:09pm
Agree with the writer, for some reason these talk shows hosts think asking questions that demean others is a good idea
Recommend
Iqbal Aswani Jun 30, 2021 08:53pm
@Riazullah Baig So what do you think is the easier way to Oscars?
Recommend
Very clear Jun 30, 2021 11:19pm
Technically obaid lady doing the same thing, what she is saying others not to do.... "don't dis other women".
Recommend
Glen D'Abreo Jul 01, 2021 01:39am
Women fighting is not a great picture for each to stand in support. But professional jealousy always manages to rear its ugly head ! Pakistani professional women are not shielded from that either.
Recommend
Rafique Jul 01, 2021 03:40am
I think Sonya hussyn is definitely right she can get any film she wants to she got more talent & beauty.
Recommend
Ali Jul 01, 2021 06:18am
Ms chinoy needs to learn that a thing called opinion. It can be given for anyone so who is Mahira Khan.
Recommend
S.Ahmad Jul 01, 2021 08:10am
Mahira khan's charm is that causes jealousy.
Recommend
ST Jul 01, 2021 08:52am
Who cares!
Recommend
Shagufta Aziz Jul 01, 2021 10:16am
@Rukhsana so true
Recommend
Shagufta Aziz Jul 01, 2021 10:17am
I like mahira but I still think acting skills of Sonya are much better
Recommend
ST Jul 01, 2021 10:48am
Sonya didnt bash Mahira but Shermeen did to Sonya. Be shameful!
Recommend
Riaz Ahmad Jul 01, 2021 03:45pm
Soniya Hassan is the one of the best actor she has done so many amazing role very well peoples like her and she replied about Mahira very true.
Recommend