Images

Actor Juhi Chawla fined INR 2 million for her petition against 5G

Actor Juhi Chawla fined INR 2 million for her petition against 5G

The Delhi High Court served her a contempt notice for the "publicity" stunt.
05 Jun, 2021

Bollywood actor Juhi Chawla believes 5G should be "certified safe" before being rolled out for the public. She submitted a plea to the Delhi High Court against 5G but the court threw out the petition and fined her.

As India readied itself for a 5G launch, Chawla announced her concerns with the technology. She claimed 5G radiations can have ill effects on human beings and wanted the technology to be tested. She and two others, Veeresh Malik and Teena Vachani, filed a suit in the Delhi High Court where they argued that "it was an established scientific fact that a 5G release could be danger of imminent nature", despite there being no credible studies to back up this assertion.

The plea was turned down by the court. Justice JR Midha said said he believed the lawsuit was filed for publicity. The court also directed that a contempt notice be issued to Chawala and the others.

Bar and Bench, an online portal in India for legal news, reported that the court said, “Plaintiffs abused [the] process of law. Costs of Rs20 lakh is imposed on plaintiffs."

The portal quoted the court as saying the suit seemed to have been done for publicity. "Juhi Chawla circulated links of the hearing on social media. No case made out for leave to institute suit (under Section 80)...or to sue in representative capacity. Plaint is defective and not maintainable. There is no personal knowledge of averments. Plaint based on legal advise not maintainable. Matter is over. You have your legal remedies.”

Additionally, in its judgement, the court announced it had imposed a fine of INR 2 million on Chawla, Malik and Vachani for abusing the process of the law.

As the news broke, Indian memers were locked and loaded.

The belief that 5G technology can affect people's health is widely considered a conspiracy theory. Believing these conspiracy theories is dangerous and for Chawala, proved costly. Remember everyone, always get your news from reputed sources.

Comments

Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad Jun 05, 2021 01:47pm
Too little, too late.
Recommend
Patriot Jun 05, 2021 01:57pm
Juhi promotes Dabur hair oil for money.Her husband is bald.
Recommend
Surya Kant Agrawal Jun 05, 2021 02:01pm
Lordships did not like the song during the hearing.
Recommend
Qamar's Jun 05, 2021 02:05pm
Leave science and technology to scientists not to actresses..
Recommend
bimal william Jun 05, 2021 02:23pm
If she is so concerned about the environment n public health she shouldn't use AC ,Fridge, Mobile Phone n other electronic gadgets that is harmful to environment n public health. as well.
Recommend
M. Saeed Jun 05, 2021 02:46pm
The court as said, the suit seemed to have been done for publicity. Then, why did the court decide a case, just as it seemed to it, without making sure??
Recommend
Solomon The King Jun 05, 2021 02:51pm
not radiation but it will certainly lead to more mental stress. I suffered pyschosi, which is hearing of voices in your ears and mind. It is when you are mental weak, you start picking of wirless frequencies and voices, and start hearing voices that travell through airwaves from one to another local. Heavier data files more mental stress. Imagine throwing, cotton buds, then sticks and then stones and hits your head while move around. the sample examples to heavy data packets. 1st it was voice, then text now images videos and all other stuff is thrown around in the air, and it is polluted
Recommend
Ali Mehdi Jun 05, 2021 02:59pm
A decision made in haste. There’s probably not tImuch precedent on this topic so the court should have done some expert review of the petition before setting up this precedent for similar future cases. The courts may not have the jurisdiction to determine the intention of plaintiff. The judgment should be based upon facts not on mere assumptions.
Recommend
Swiss Neutral Jun 05, 2021 03:30pm
It is pay back time
Recommend
Ajay Kumar Jun 05, 2021 04:06pm
She could not explain what and how 5G is harmful ? She had no knowledge about tje radiation and how will it affect life. So..... Also she shared the link for online proceedings and some one joined the proceedings and started singing songs.
Recommend
kp Jun 05, 2021 04:14pm
People who has never been to Radio and Microwave engineering are filing petition without any technical data. deserves her right , only the fine was so small.
Recommend
Sane Mind1st Jun 05, 2021 04:38pm
@Patriot Nice one.
Recommend
A Jun 05, 2021 05:17pm
There are 110 connections per 100 citizens in India. World average is 104. Pakistan has 85.70. There should be study in India and all south Asian countries. The way cellular towers and networks are used so that signal never drops there has be a quantitative study on amount of radiation.
Recommend
Multani Jun 05, 2021 07:05pm
Chinese 5G technology is best, Indians cannot match it at all and will likely fail .
Recommend
Gurcharan Jun 05, 2021 08:23pm
@Multani "Chinese 5G technology is best, Indians cannot match it at all and will likely fail ." What do you know id Ibduab 5G technology?
Recommend
Alishba Jun 05, 2021 08:29pm
@Multani We should worry about creating Pakistani 5G first.
Recommend
Sri Jun 05, 2021 09:08pm
@Ali Mehdi, Issue was she did not make any efforts writing to authorities, experts, govt etc and filed a plea directly in the court.. another interesting thing is once the hearing was announced via online, shared that link on her Twitter handle and asked all her fans to join which is a bit bizarre..
Recommend
Brahmchari Jun 05, 2021 11:09pm
Juhi did for coming back in lime light Otherwise she was going to be removed from Ad market ..No films for quite some time ...
Recommend
Ha Tim Tayee Jun 06, 2021 12:13am
Juhi Chawla has not impressed a court with her self promotion!
Recommend
Ha Tim Tayee Jun 06, 2021 12:14am
@Qamar: Yes!
Recommend
Ha Tim Tayee Jun 06, 2021 12:19am
@Multani: Rubbish!
Recommend
Changez Khan Jun 06, 2021 01:52am
This is totally a stupid part by the Indian government.
Recommend
GK Jun 06, 2021 06:51am
Do your home work first. You have to approach the concerned department, ministry etc... and only if there is a dispute then go to court.
Recommend
EEsan Jun 06, 2021 08:12am
@M. Saeed ..The courts did not decide on the case. They just refused the hearing of the case and threw it out by calling it baseless.
Recommend
EEsan Jun 06, 2021 08:15am
@Multani 5G is a wireless technical standard that has been jointly developed by many participants. It is NOT a Chinese technology. China is just one of the contributors in the technical standards. Get educated before making a fool of yourself by blindly singing China’s or anyone else’s praises.
Recommend
Richard Jun 06, 2021 09:25am
@Ali Mehdi.. There is a government portal to address our convlcern on 5G.. There is a procedure to follow. She did not raise her concern to ministry. She went straight to court which was wrong m
Recommend
Parvez Jun 06, 2021 02:01pm
juhi Chawla's position on G5 ....that is needs to certified by responsible independent people " as safe "..... makes good sense.
Recommend
LgbtqX Jun 08, 2021 06:13am
Hope she won't try it again.
Recommend