Images

Fashion mogul accuses designers of 'enslaving women' with Islamic styles

Fashion mogul accuses designers of 'enslaving women' with Islamic styles

Pierre Berge was critical of big fashion chains that followed Dolce & Gabbana in catering specifically to Muslim market.
Updated 30 Mar, 2016

PARIS: Former fashion mogul Pierre Berge lashed out on Wednesday at designers creating Islamic clothing and headscarves, accusing them of taking part in the "enslavement of women".

The French businessman, partner of the late fashion legend Yves Saint Laurent, took aim at the wave of big fashion chains that have followed the Italian designers Dolce & Gabbana in catering specifically to the Muslim market.

"I am scandalised," he told Europe 1 French radio.

"Creators should have nothing to do with Islamic fashion. Designers are there to make women more beautiful, to give them their freedom, not to collaborate with this dictatorship which imposes this abominable thing by which we hide women and make them live a hidden life."

"Renounce the money and have some principles," he declared, lashing the new fashion for "modest" Muslim-friendly lines.

His comments came as the French families minister, Laurence Rossignol, sparked outrage on social media as she compared women who followed this trend with "negroes who supported slavery".

Her office later told AFP she had not intended to cause offence but was referring to an abolitionist tract by the French philosopher Montesquieu, "De l'esclavage des nègres" ("On the Enslavement of Negroes").

Earlier this year Dolce & Gabbana became the first major western brand to openly aim at capturing a corner of the Islamic fashion market ─ estimated to be worth $260 billion ─ with its Abaya range.

It included 14 abayas or ankle-length dresses, which it matched with embroidered headscarves and hijabs.


"Renounce the money and have some principles," he declared, lashing the new fashion for "modest" Muslim-friendly lines.


'Burqinis'

The Swedish giant H&M followed their lead, using a veiled Muslim women in its advertising campaign, with the Japanese brand Uniqlo earlier this month announcing it would begin selling hijabs in its London stores.

The British brand Marks & Spencer has also put its toe in the water, marketing full-body "burqini" swimming costumes in its online store.

Last year Zara, Tommy Hilfiger, Oscar de la Renta and Mango all launched varyingly "modest" collections to coincide with the holy Muslim month of Ramadan, picking up on the success of a small DKNY line the previous year.

But Berge, 85, who ran the Yves Saint Laurent fashion house for four decades, decried their "opportunism".

"These creators who are taking part in the enslavement of women should ask themselves some questions,” he added.

"In one way they are complicit, and all this to make make money. Principles should come before money," Berge argued.

Comments

Hamaad Mar 30, 2016 08:09pm
Muslim fashion styles are in to stay, whether you like it or not.
Recommend
PK Mar 30, 2016 08:16pm
If covering women with cloths is standard of freedom than Pierre Berge is also a culprit of the same phenomenon since he is part of fashion that say covered women 60%!
Recommend
Shahid Mar 30, 2016 08:20pm
"Designers are there to give women freedom" . Freedom from what, from excessive clothes? Why would designers like women to wear less and men to wear more? Let women for a change stay covered and work on men's freedom (from clothes).
Recommend
The Observer Mar 30, 2016 08:29pm
At one end they talk about freedom at the other if someone choses to be as he/she likes, call it enslavement.
Recommend
Raj Mar 30, 2016 08:30pm
Disclaimer - I'm a Hindu originally from India - here's my thought - up for debate - When I look at girls 10-15 years old, covered in those kind of clothes, I think what kind of father would take away the freedom of their daughters by doing this - possibly not imposing, but by brainwashing (and he has possibly been brainwashed too) that girls should cover themselves up from head to toe.
Recommend
Mahmood Mar 30, 2016 08:30pm
Clearly Bergel does not understand Islamic culture and the choices women enjoy for their daily attire. I think someone walking around with a designer's initials in BOLD on the chest is more of a fashion slave than Muslim women dressing modestly.
Recommend
SyedChaudhryGangaDinKhan Mar 30, 2016 08:33pm
"Fashion mogul accuses designers of 'enslaving women' with Islamic styles" If it is enslavement, why are so many women falling for it? Doesn't your statement indirectly question women's intelligence?
Recommend
khan Mar 30, 2016 08:37pm
Giving women freedom or exploiting them for their sexuality. Islamic dress gives women the freedom to allow people to see what they think and speak rather than expose thmseleves to the whims of wicked old men like Berge who although are themselves covered from head to toe like muslim women yet want to exploit and strip women on the name of freedom.
Recommend
Jason Mar 30, 2016 08:38pm
"Enslavement of Women". Really. That is the best criticism you can come up with? Many women do this out of will, especially the ones who are not bound by any laws or family directives. Even if they are bound by either, do they not deserve to have variety of choices for what they wear? I commend all designers who have taken a new step in designing new fashions for women long ignored by the fashion industry. How ironic that the local talent is putting less material for clothing, and Western designers are designing clothes to cover the Eastern values.
Recommend
سے Shaam Mar 30, 2016 09:28pm
Correct Assumption!
Recommend
Ayesha Mar 30, 2016 09:34pm
Wonderful. Thank you for bringing my enslavement to my attention, Pierre Berge.
Recommend
Haider Mar 30, 2016 09:39pm
Sounds like a bigot to me. He can't accept that everyone doesn't live by his worldview, lifestyle and way of life.
Recommend
H L Mar 30, 2016 09:53pm
Wait and see more bigotry of Yves Saint Laurent. Freedom = being bashful or otherwise?
Recommend
NASR Mar 30, 2016 09:53pm
@سے Shaam Totally Wrong Assumption
Recommend
NASR Mar 30, 2016 09:57pm
"enslavement of women" What can a 85 yrs old think worst than this after ruling the fashion world for four decades.
Recommend
Najjee Mar 30, 2016 09:58pm
I totally agree!
Recommend
Reality Bites Mar 30, 2016 10:03pm
Its a business move from the fashion designers. People who already wear the drab looking clothing can now be a little more palatable.
Recommend
Hasan Mar 30, 2016 10:14pm
@Ayesha Haha, good answer. Hasan
Recommend
Satyam vada Mar 30, 2016 10:25pm
"Creators should have nothing to do with Islamic fashion. Designers are there to make women more beautiful, to give them their freedom, " he alone will define what is beauty and what is freedom!
Recommend
flipflop Mar 30, 2016 10:31pm
The more colourful and glamourous the hijab becomes it starts to lose its core idea amd purpose so I really don't get the idea behind designer hijabs. I am not saying that women should not do fashion or should not dress the way they desire, but perhaps ot would be wise to preserve the purpose the purpose behind hijab. In no way I am trying to offend any one here ,so sorry if someone got offended.....
Recommend
Muhammad Abbas Mar 30, 2016 10:41pm
strange.......those who wear mini skirts are then Sami-slave....so they should through away dress and should live undressed........really shameful
Recommend
Irene McConachy Mar 30, 2016 11:01pm
Wow, Apparently Pierre Berge should take a little time to talk to actual Muslim women about how they feel about this before he feels he needs to "save them from themselves." A very colonialist attitude... Not being Muslim myself, I'm eyeing a few of those outfits for my closet! Beautiful!
Recommend
Ghaznavi Mar 30, 2016 11:03pm
Former fashion mogul Pierre Berge has no clue about the world and perhaps too arrogant to accept diversity. There is a world and cultures beyond France. Cultures which are no less proud and civilized then the french. There are women who choose to wear Islamic dress by choice. but in his little mind he cannot comprehend it.
Recommend
Reality Mar 30, 2016 11:09pm
"Creators should have nothing to do with Islamic fashion. Designers are there to make women more beautiful, to give them their freedom, not to collaborate with this dictatorship which imposes this abominable thing by which we hide women and make them live a hidden life." Are you serious, is this a comment of YSL partner? Well, I do like women who wear jeans and tea-shirt and I have no problem with that. Then why is the problem with scarf ? Cloths should remain cloths, as long as they cover the body, and that is what is meant for.
Recommend
Nick Mar 30, 2016 11:21pm
That's a clear case of Islamophobia...now you are concerned about 'Islamic dresses' also..What's wrong in introducing that to the fashion world??
Recommend
Eastern Mar 30, 2016 11:32pm
Haters gonna hate
Recommend
Imtiaz Faruqui Mar 31, 2016 12:01am
@Hamaad So is the suppression of women and domestic abuse by Muslim men , no power to women hence failing as a state. Covering the woman make her feel insecure ,scared and inconfident in all walks of life.
Recommend
NASH Mar 31, 2016 12:35am
Pierre Berge should realize that freedom comes from mind not by showing more skin in the name of fashion.
Recommend
Larkanavi Mar 31, 2016 12:47am
Market forces, not racist outbursts, will determine the popularity or otherwise of Islamic Fashion Designs. This so called former fashion mogul can shout at the top of his voice but it will make no difference if businesses all over the world find Islamic women's fashion a lucrative business.
Recommend
divergence Mar 31, 2016 01:55am
the lesser said, the better
Recommend
divergence Mar 31, 2016 01:56am
Commercialization, there are customers, hence production. It is sheer business
Recommend
Albo Mar 31, 2016 03:28am
The first thing Pierre Berge should do is try and understand that the Muslim garments are not enslaving or oppressing. There are cases where they have been used to oppress women but this was no the original intention and this should be understood.
Recommend
Hari Mar 31, 2016 04:47am
Colourful penguins and post boxes. Lol.
Recommend
asli bk Mar 31, 2016 05:51am
designer handcuffs are still handcuffs.
Recommend
Talha Mar 31, 2016 05:55am
Ladies who work at churches wear the same clothing with different style mr. Berge. Have them unslaved first before our amazing culture.
Recommend
aman Mar 31, 2016 06:07am
Mr. Pierre, thinks women out of clothes are liberated. This man is sick.
Recommend
Seher Hassany Mar 31, 2016 06:24am
Really, this is an old school judgemental view! Women get to choose to dress modestly if they so please...they are not enslaved....for many it's a conscious choice to honour their beliefs... Modest fashion clothing gives many of them a sense of self esteem, it's as if their beliefs matter and are being taken seriously by the fashion industry...it justifies and establishes their perception of womanhood... It's ok to have multiple identitities of womanhood ... It's a celebration of diversity!
Recommend
Bakhtyar Mar 31, 2016 06:30am
High time a blindfold for Muslim men should be designed.Has anybody noticed the lust with which they stare at other women.If the Almighty has endowed a woman with grace and beauty who is man to cover her up.Carry out a survey, an honest one please and ask how many women really support being HIDDEN and choking when they have a right to breathe freely.The world will be shocked to read the results.
Recommend
shabut Mar 31, 2016 06:37am
If covering women is equivalent to enslavement then uncovering them is making women a sex commodity.
Recommend
vijayan Mar 31, 2016 06:56am
@Hamaad.. Agreed, I saw this really cool woman's swimming costume , it covered everything but the eyes. I was to die for!!!! Who can resist that!!
Recommend
Zala Mar 31, 2016 07:48am
Women studying in Harvard, Princeton, Oxford and other elite school choose to wear hijab. They are definitely not oppressed. Why can't the west accept that millions of Muslim women choose to cover up because they want to follow their religion.
Recommend
Agha Ata Mar 31, 2016 08:00am
If you go deep into the history of why and how women like to be groomed, you will find that necklaces, bangles and bracelets are also the remanents of slavery when they were chained.
Recommend
Jawad Pakistani Mar 31, 2016 08:16am
She is right. The designers have to stop this nonsense fashion of headscarfs. Headscarf is not a fashion but a religion mark.
Recommend
Akil Akhtar Mar 31, 2016 08:39am
Yes fashion should only cater for western women...LOL
Recommend
Pakistan110 Mar 31, 2016 09:00am
Oh Common! Don't discriminate based on protection of women, you call it enslavement? I don't know what problem so-called western world has with our divine Islamic principles based on real values, reasons and justifications. First they had a problem with Beard in men, now they have problem with Scarf on women? So disgusting!
Recommend
Reality Mar 31, 2016 09:33am
Was that really YSL's partner comment ? I don't see any problem in scarf or jeans, as long as it serve the purpose to cover the body. After all. clothes are clothes same as cup of tea is a cup of tea.
Recommend
zebswati Mar 31, 2016 09:34am
So you think women only looks good in bikinis ? , Let the women decide what they want to ware and what not , the more choice they have more fashion industry will grow !
Recommend
Freda Shah Mar 31, 2016 10:01am
This is more Arab, rather than Muslim fashion.
Recommend
SIAK Mar 31, 2016 10:09am
Wow, what a hypocrite! They have been enslaving women, in particular, and mankind, in general, for years in the name of no-holds-barred fashion.
Recommend
Shiekh Magoon Mar 31, 2016 10:48am
Mr Berge are you saying that you are restricting the ways women want to dress. i.e. if they want to don a burqa, they should not because it contradicts your opinion.
Recommend
Abbas Ali Mar 31, 2016 11:23am
If this is fashion, then world is heading for disaster. Please don't tell me they look gorgeous in tents. More like suicide bomber.
Recommend
Roha Mar 31, 2016 11:26am
Muslim women don't have to show skin to get freedom. We get freedom and respect with modesty. Mini skirts is not our thing, so what?
Recommend
Khalid Mar 31, 2016 11:53am
There are millions of Muslim women who willingly wear hijab and feel comfortable and many don't wear and they are ok as well with it. The big companies are just following simple economics principle i.e demand and supply. If there are consumers, then every company has a right to tap that market.
Recommend
best ally Mar 31, 2016 11:54am
"burqini"? interesting...
Recommend
NAUSHEEN M Mar 31, 2016 11:57am
It is not about enslaving women, it's about their own choice and how they like to dress. No one is forced to follow if they do not like it, just as not everyone wears crazy senseless dresses they showcase normally at fashion shows.
Recommend
NAUSHEEN M Mar 31, 2016 11:59am
@Abbas Ali RIP to your mentality.
Recommend
Syed Mar 31, 2016 12:16pm
Very Nice Move of International Fashion Industry. Keep it up. They should take these sort of moves in future also.....
Recommend
Philosopher (from Japan) Mar 31, 2016 12:21pm
The women enslavenent doesn't come from Muslim clothing or any other clothing. The west has made the women enslaved through a so called empowerment. Male Chauvinists strategically insert nudity in women's clothing for their own satisfaction. Otherwise women feel more comfortable and enjoy more freedom with full body cover. It proves that women enslavement comes in less clothing. After all, slaves are not allowed to have more clothes than their masters to show the inferiority status they might have.
Recommend
AA Mar 31, 2016 12:35pm
I really dont understand what he meant by this statement "Designers are there to make women more beautiful, to give them their freedom" by this context strippers are the most beautiful and free women in the world.
Recommend
Syed Mar 31, 2016 12:40pm
Nice Move in Fashion Industry.
Recommend
Arif Nayani Mar 31, 2016 12:50pm
If modesty is enslavement for them then those indigenous people who live fully naked would be most liberal and progressive for them..I advice these frogs to look out of their wells as Muslim women are not living any hidden lives except in some parts of Arab world where their own pampered dictators have implemented radical brand of sharia in the name of Islam..
Recommend
Kh. T. Hyder Mar 31, 2016 02:23pm
Very rightly said Berge "Principles should come before money," - and according to "Principles" of nearly 1.5 billion Muslims, their women look more attractive/ graceful when covered. Obviously the Designers have started following the "Principles" of their targeted market.
Recommend
smash Mar 31, 2016 04:00pm
Completely agree with Pierre Berge. This is not fashion. This just glorifying enslavement.
Recommend
Reality Mar 31, 2016 04:26pm
There was a time when YSL was doing good, in-fact at that time fashion industry around the world didn't focus on women of that part of the world who like to have scarf. We should not forget that YSL partner Mr. Pieree Berge is now 85 years old, and I have no clue of business status of YSL, no offence please.
Recommend
Good taste Mar 31, 2016 04:51pm
Money talks.
Recommend
Good taste Mar 31, 2016 04:57pm
@Seher Hassany Every thing is gold plated with the word "honour" as it is some magic word. Honour dressing, honour killing. Makes it all sound OK but far from it.
Recommend
Sarb Mar 31, 2016 08:32pm
Isn't that business work on market demands. So if there is market for Muslim clothes what is wrong. with it. I think Mr. Pierre Berge you are trying to revive attention towards you like Donald Trump is doing.
Recommend
nasr Mar 31, 2016 10:49pm
@flipflop There is nowhere stipulated about the design, color of Hijab so adding some design and color won't do any harm
Recommend
Mustafa Apr 01, 2016 03:00am
Indeed there has always been a tug of war between haves and haves not.
Recommend
Haroon cma Apr 01, 2016 05:59am
You think every body is entitled to your opinion but the ground reality dictates other wise. If it is so abhorrent, this will not last. This will be dictated by market.
Recommend
shakeel Jalil Apr 01, 2016 01:42pm
As usual french , twisting events is the part of old habit
Recommend
Shariq Apr 02, 2016 09:25am
Abaya's from western brands doesn't mean they are promoting Islamic ways of life. They are only catering to demand.
Recommend