Images

Indian singer Lucky Ali gets backlash for endearing tweet about Palestinian children

Indian singer Lucky Ali gets backlash for endearing tweet about Palestinian children

Seemingly pro-Israel accounts flooded his post with hateful comments.
Updated 30 Oct, 2024

Veteran Indian singer Lucky Ali found himself in the centre of a social media storm following a heartfelt message expressing solidarity with Palestine.

On X (formerly Twitter), Ali shared a post that read: “All the children of Palestine are mine.” His statement reflected the shared grief many feel amid the ongoing violence in Gaza, where Israel’s relentless bombings have killed, injured, and traumatised countless civilians, including children.

However, Ali’s message did not sit well with certain Indian users who swiftly attacked him online.

Seemingly pro-Israel accounts flooded his post with hateful comments, questioning his loyalty to India and mocking his compassion for Palestinian children.

Several of the comments were personal and offensive. One user sarcastically asked, “Why are you so far from your children then?” while another mocked him, writing, “Palestine ke abbu, why have you left your kids in Palestine and [are] living in India? You must go there.”

Others went even further, asking him why he’s even “living in luxury in India” when his children are in Palestine, inadvertently implying that India is not a place for Muslims or Palestine supporters. “Why are you living in luxury here in India? Why don’t you go to Palestine to meet them personally?” the troll wrote. Another chimed in, “Now be a responsible parent and go there.”

Despite the hostility, Ali seemed unfazed by the barrage of criticism. In one exchange, a user expressed disappointment, saying, “I held you in very high regard, but slowly you’re losing it, Lucky bhai.” Ali responded firmly, “You don’t belong here.”

The hateful responses highlight the challenges public figures face when speaking out on contentious issues, especially under Modi’s government in India. The backlash against Ali appears to reflect not just ideological opposition but also a desire to discourage others from raising their voices for Palestine.

However, Ali’s refusal to back down at a time when it is easier to remain silent reflects his bravery and his message resonates with those who believe in humanity beyond borders.

Comments

Free Palestine Oct 29, 2024 06:25pm
Nothing wrong what he did, everyone with good heart and mind, feel pain in death of thousands of innocent people in unjust war in Gaza, Ukraine and Middle East. This killing of innocent civilians in Gaza must stop now.
Recommend
Zahid Latif Oct 29, 2024 06:43pm
“All the children of Palestine are mine.” What a great line by a great singer. A salute to his courage.
Recommend
UD Oct 29, 2024 06:55pm
Who is responsible for about 43,000 Palestinian deaths and plight of children over there ?
Recommend
UD Oct 29, 2024 06:58pm
What is he doing in India ? Aren't people right ? Is it not his duty to go back when his children are dying there ? What do you say ?
Recommend
MA Oct 29, 2024 07:06pm
Distress,pain, agony and suffering of humans is test of empathy, love and feeling for others irrespective of any discrimination.In the tragic situation of Palestine, people felt pain which is seen in the protest and solidarity marches all over the globe.Brave side with the truth and feel suffering of others.
Recommend
Imran Khan Oct 29, 2024 07:17pm
A little israel lives in india...they are BJP fascists
Recommend
John Malik Oct 29, 2024 07:24pm
Israelis time and again have rejected right wing hindu sympathies and support so what gives about this outrage over the singer’s heartfelt tweet? I guess the insecurity and a desire to be acknowledged is what these lowlife seek.
Recommend
Nauman Oct 29, 2024 07:52pm
Love you Lucky Ali
Recommend
Azad Hussain Oct 29, 2024 07:55pm
Luck ail your not alone millions are with you around the world remember we have one life we answer to high power injustice is a giving right for us speak up against when we see it front of our eyes remember courage comes from with in faith lights the way
Recommend
Sarbjit Sidhu Oct 29, 2024 07:58pm
All children in this world are equal and they are children of human race. They are our children. Any one who distinguishes them by religion or any other means is a very low and evil one.
Recommend
Uturn Oct 29, 2024 08:13pm
Everyone has the freedom of speech even the so-called "trolls".
Recommend
ahtesham asif Oct 29, 2024 08:14pm
HE IS GREAT NOBLE MAN
Recommend
ahtesham asif Oct 29, 2024 08:15pm
A LOT OF RESPECT IN MY COUNTRY USA
Recommend
Mushtaq Oct 29, 2024 08:42pm
Why Lucky Ali is being targeted like this when he made comment for the cause of Umma ?? How about giving him asylum in Pakistan ?
Recommend
kamal chowkidar Oct 29, 2024 08:51pm
He is getting what he deserves.
Recommend
Masood Khan Oct 29, 2024 09:02pm
A typical BJP, RSS, VHP rant against anybody that sympathizes with the Muslim cause or death. These jobless, Indian trolls sitting on a keyboard just punch out these words because they think that maybe Israel would accept them and give them a janitorial job.
Recommend
Abdul Oct 29, 2024 09:03pm
Some Indians are going overboard...I understand that they are in a revivalist mode trying to correct historical wrongs of the partition and what happened to Pandits in the valley....but please keep your perspective. Don't lose your humanity.
Recommend
Joji Jan Oct 29, 2024 09:10pm
Thanks for standing up for the cause of Palestine Childrens, I like this comment Whether it my blood or that of a stranger It is the blood of a human Whether war is in the west or in the east Its the murder of universal peace
Recommend
Captain Oct 29, 2024 10:42pm
He a legendary singer. In one of his interviews he emphatically said I am a practicing Muslim and Madina is may favourite place in the world. I stand with him at this point in time
Recommend
Wellwisher Oct 29, 2024 10:43pm
'Under Modi Government'!! Well, these things bound to happen with any celebrity worldwide, there is a quite a trend to bring Modi in each and every matter however unrelated it may be!
Recommend
tuk Oct 29, 2024 10:43pm
These Indian trolls need to get down from their high horse! It is still a 3rd world country and spiraling down!!
Recommend
Pravin Oct 29, 2024 10:59pm
I am from India and sympathize with Palestine children but not with Palestine leader who started with terrorist strike on October 7th. In return, Israel has a right to strike back. So, the leaders in Palestine are responsible for the current state.
Recommend
Anonymouseee Oct 29, 2024 11:02pm
India and Hindu extremists are worst than terrorist Israel and Nazi Germans.
Recommend
Gurpreet Singh Oct 29, 2024 11:52pm
Many Indian celebrities have openly supported Palestine. There will be those who appreciate it and those who criticize it, since its a contentious topic not just in India but throughout the world. Stop cherry picking from the comments and making this an India or Modi thing. I can say this with utmost confidence that Indians have a lot more freedom to support Palestine than Pakistanis have, to support Israel.
Recommend
M.Saeed Oct 30, 2024 12:29am
Hate is antihuman vice that has so far remained beyond the reach of human achievements in the whole of the universe!
Recommend
PRAMOD C AMIN Oct 30, 2024 12:46am
those insensitive people do not care if it is not thier own childrens. Alibhai you do not need their approval
Recommend
Parbat Oct 30, 2024 01:05am
Wow!! BJP zealots
Recommend
Zia Oct 30, 2024 01:06am
Can not believe the ignorance of the above users who commented. They really need to understand the context. Next time you complain about something / someone or show solidarity with someone or something you go there physically or else its useless. Amazing is the focus on what lucky Ali said and not a word abt the ones who are suffering! Break the shackles of ignorance.
Recommend
Sohail Ahmed Oct 30, 2024 01:16am
Some people are emotionally sick. Salute for Lucky Ali to express his support for the oppressed
Recommend
syed H naqvi Oct 30, 2024 01:34am
India under MODI is fast transforming into an Islamic phobia country even though they have a very large muslim population. I think they needs further division and the northern parts like Punjab should become Khalistan and and U.P and behar should secede and become Beharup.
Recommend
Zulfiqar Oct 30, 2024 02:39am
Racism and Islamophobia in India is at a another level
Recommend
Amin Oct 30, 2024 02:56am
A typical Indian response!
Recommend
Ron Oct 30, 2024 03:30am
Palestinian kids not only belong to Ali but to each and every Muslim of the world. We all are one
Recommend
Johnw Oct 30, 2024 06:25am
The poor man's mediocre career was over long ago. There's isn't much he can do besides stirring up a controversial tweet.
Recommend
GaawarJqt Oct 30, 2024 06:38am
These fake celebrities will show superficial sympathy to get public support qnd for TRP. The truth is they really don't care about anyone other than themselves, forget about Palestinians kids.
Recommend
Bingo Oct 30, 2024 07:12am
Indians support india. When china invaded india, no one supported india
Recommend
Citizen Oct 30, 2024 07:56am
Lucky Ali should shift to Gaza to show solidarity
Recommend
Rama Oct 30, 2024 08:36am
You should not leave your children in such a dire situation, go their and protect them
Recommend
Sharjeel Syed Oct 30, 2024 09:05am
Hindtuwa mindset can't be any better. RSS ideology has governed India, irrespective of any political party sitting in the center. Gujrat ethnic cleansing of Muslims is one such example and there are thousands of others. Response to Lucky Ali's post is just a reflection of the intolerant mindset that strongly exists in Indian society.
Recommend
RIAZ Oct 30, 2024 09:40am
love you ALI
Recommend
Ram Prasad Oct 30, 2024 10:00am
Everyone has an opinion with reasons. Both sides
Recommend
Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad Oct 30, 2024 10:21am
As expected.
Recommend
D J Saikia Oct 30, 2024 11:27am
Oh dear Lucky Ali Please take care of your family first rather than fathering the innocents children of Gaza.
Recommend
NYS Oct 30, 2024 12:49pm
India Way to snub voices that raised pro Palestine Isn't it disgusting law
Recommend
SANE Oct 30, 2024 12:58pm
of course the anti muslim sentiment in India cannot stand this tweet
Recommend
SA Oct 31, 2024 12:42am
If you were an educate human being and knew the history well, you would not have asked this silly question re. "Who is responsible for about 43,000 Palestinian deaths and plight of children over there ?"
Recommend
Laila Oct 31, 2024 03:26pm
@Anonymouseee First you say India (a country of 1 billion+ people of which 250 million are Muslims) and then in same breath you say 'Hindu extremists'. Extremists are usually a minority so you must decide, whether you are accusing an entire nation for the actions of a few or whether minority extremists are not extreme but represent the average Indian (including Indian Muslims). Would it be ok if our Pakistani nation was called terrorists just because of the actions a few misguided extremists? No. So let's not malign an entire nation. Maybe you should actually meet and talk to Indians. Most are nice people. I have met Indian Muslims and none shared your concerns. I swear this bubble we live in in Pakistan without exposure to other nations, cultures, other Muslims and religions has made us very narrowminded. The day is not far away when Palestine will be free and we will be able to travel there and then we will complain how they are "westernised" and not "proper Muslims".
Recommend