Beyonce’s Cowboy Carter drips history and joy

Beyonce’s Cowboy Carter drips history and joy

News of her album magnified a wider conversation on the long history of Black artists in country music, and the racist backlash they experience.
29 Mar, 2024

Beyonce’s Cowboy Carter is a full-throated ode to her southern roots, a rollicking revue of an album that also deals a vital history lesson on the Black lineage of country music.

The 27-track, highly anticipated record that dropped on Friday is the second act of her Renaissance trilogy, a sonically diverse jamboree flavoured with strings and pedal steel guitar.

Beyonce has been a versatile showbiz fixture for nearly three decades, but for all the caps she’s worn, the Houston-bred megastar’s cowboy hat has stayed within reach: Queen Bey has always been country.

But even the powerful artist — who has more Grammy wins than any other artist in the business, ever — has brushed up against the overwhelmingly white, male gatekeepers of country music who have long dictated the genre’s perceived boundaries.

She notably received racist comments after performing what was then her most country song to date, ‘Daddy Lessons’, at the 2016 Country Music Association Awards alongside The Chicks.

And while her first two singles off the album were released last month to chart-topping acclaim and ecstasy from fans, there were also predictable, bigoted eyebrow raises from some circles.

At the same time, news of her album magnified a wider conversation on the long history of Black artists in country music, and the persistent racist backlash they’ve continued to experience in those spaces.

A Texan raised by a mother from Louisiana and a father from Alabama, Beyonce tackled the perceived controversy over her full country turn on the track ‘Ameriican Requiem’.

“They used to say I spoke, ‘Too country’ / Then the rejection came, said I wasn’t, ‘Country enough’ / Said I wouldn’t saddle up, but if that ain’t country, tell me, what is?” Beyonce sings on the track whose musical allusions include Buffalo Springfield’s classic ‘For What It’s Worth’. “Tread my bare feet on solid ground for years / They don’t, don’t know how hard I had to fight for this.”

With technical mastery, she delivers a blend of styles including various country subsets as well as rap, dance, soul, funk, rock and gospel. It’s a full-colour display of just how rich music can grow outside the dusty strictures of genre.

“Genres are a funny little concept, aren’t they?” says an intro to ‘Spaghettii’. “In theory, they have a simple definition that’s easy to understand – but in practice, well, some may feel confined.”

Beyonce X Dolly

The album is rife with socio-cultural nods both in lyric and style, a honkified celebration of country-western’s musicography and influences that are also grounded in the African American spirituals and fiddle tunes rock blossomed out of.

And Cowboy Carter features genre elders in the form of a broadcast from a fictional radio station — a hint at well-documented struggles women and people of colour still face getting airtime on country radio — whose hosts included Willie Nelson, country pioneer Linda Martell and the legend herself, Dolly Parton.

In performing a rendition of Parton’s ‘Jolene’ — the singer fears her partner might leave her for another — Beyonce recalls her seminal album Lemonade which excavated the infidelity of her husband, Jay-Z.

Parton’s intro lays bare the parallels in describing “that hussy with the good hair,” a direct reference to the 2016 Beyonce track ‘Sorry’. Also on the sprawling album is a Beyonce cover of Paul McCartney’s ‘Blackbiird’, stylised with a double-i spelling.

McCartney wrote the 1968 song about the Little Rock Nine, Black teenagers who became Civil Rights Movement icons when they were the first to enter a previously all-white high school in Arkansas, ushering in desegregation in the US South.

Beyonce-style ode to joy

But as is her custom, Beyonce seamlessly blends her socio-political commentary with a full-blown party, a celebration of mirth and her own self-love.

‘Ya Ya’ is a sultry, psychedelic soul mashup that manages to sample both Nancy Sinatra’s ‘These Boots Are Made For Walkin’ and The Beach Boys, while still dropping point after point.

“My family lived and died in America,” she belts. “Whole lotta red and then white and blue/ History can’t be erased.” “Are you lookin’ for a new America / Are you tired, workin’ time-and-a-half for half the pay, ya-ya.”

‘Sweet Honey Buckiin’ incorporates hip hop and house with strums on loop, among her songs that hat-tip to the first act of Renaissance, which celebrated electronica’s Black origins and evolution.

Tanner Adell, Willie Jones and Shaboozey, all acclaimed Black country artists, feature on Cowboy Carter, as do Miley Cyrus — Parton’s goddaughter — and Post Malone, stars who’ve also drifted between pop and country.

‘Texas Hold ‘Em’, the album’s lead single, includes Rhiannon Giddens — who often uses her platform to celebrate the African American roots of country — on the banjo and viola.

No matter how Nashville reacts to Cowboy Carter, Beyonce has made it clear she’ll have the last word.

“This ain’t a Country album,” she posted on Instagram recently.

“This is a ‘Beyonce’ album. “


Syed Hasni Mar 29, 2024 01:29pm
She can say whatever she wants, the album would have worked better if split into two separate albums, with one concentrating purely on the country influenced. Cowboy Carter still proves Beyoncé is impressively capable of doing whatever she wants. When it comes to country singing, no one is better than Shania Twain. I have to say to Beyonce "You don't Impress me much."
Taj Ahmad Mar 29, 2024 01:53pm
Singer Beyonce simply amazing and beautiful American model singer after Witney Houston.
Tony Fernandes Mar 30, 2024 05:01am
Well written comments - what I would call constructive criticism