Images

Shah Rukh Khan offers dua at Lata Mangeshkar's funeral, BJP leader accuses him of 'spitting' on her

Shah Rukh Khan offers dua at Lata Mangeshkar's funeral, BJP leader accuses him of 'spitting' on her

Arun Yadav sparked controversy by posting a video of the actor when he lowered his mask to blow on her after reciting a dua.
Updated 07 Feb, 2022

The "Nightingale of India," Lata Mangeshkar, passed away on Feb 6 at Mumbai's Breach Candy Hospital, where she was being treated for Covid-19 and pneumonia. After almost a month of being in the hospital, the legendary singer's condition had changed from stable to critical. She was cremated in Mumbai with full state honours and her funeral was attended by many people, including PM Narendra Modi and Bollywood actors Shah Rukh Khan, Aamir Khan, Ranbir Kapoor, Vidya Balan and Shraddha Kapoor.

Stars pay tribute to the legendary singer

Crowds gathered outside Mangeshkar's home, from where her coffin was taken to a park where it was publicly cremated. PM Modi was among those who laid flowers on the pyre as hundreds gathered to say a final farewell.

Aamir, along with his daughter Ira, and Ranbir were pictured paying their respects to the iconic singer.

Photo: NDTV
Photo: NDTV

Balan was also present to honour Mangeshkar.

Photo: NDTV
Photo: NDTV

Shraddha, who is related to Mangeshkar, was at the funeral and also visited the hospital on Feb 6.

Photo: NDTV
Photo: NDTV

The government has announced two days of mourning across the country and the national flag will be flown at half-mast throughout India.

Shah Rukh Khan also paid tribute to the legendary singer by reciting a dua [prayer] but when he lowered his mask to blow air on her — a customary act known as phoonkna — some people claimed he spit on her.

Arun Yadav, state-in-charge of BJP Haryana IT, posted a video on Twitter asking whether the actor had spit.

BJP Uttar Pradesh Spokesperson Prashant Umrao repeated the claim, saying "Shahrukh is Spitting!"

Former CBI director M Nageswara Rao tagged the actor in a tweet asking if he'd spit and said being a public figure he is "required to give public clarification immediately."

This is not the first time the My Name is Khan actor has been targeted solely on the basis of his religion — right before the big release of his film Pathan, "Boycott Shah Rukh Khan" started trending on Indian social media. Some Twitterati claimed that the Bollywood star had hurt some religious sentiments over and over again. They shared images, news clippings and incidents from the past where Khan was seen speaking in support of Pakistani cricket players, speaking of intolerance in India and his photos with PM Imran Khan, branding him as a "Pakistan lover" and a terrorist.

In Oct 2021, Shah Rukh's son Aryan Khan was taken into custody by India's Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) alleged possession of banned drugs and substance abuse on board a cruise ship and denied bail, dragging the case on for 28 days before Aryan was finally released from jail. Netizens claimed that this was purely a bigoted reaction and was treated with measures too extreme for "alleged" drug possession.

The actor's respectful gesture at Mangeshkar's funeral, however, won hearts all over the nation and people were quick to rush to his defence. Congress leader Supriya Shrinate responded and accused Yadav of spreading hatred. "You aren’t just a bigot but pure evil to twist a dua said in reverence of the departed soul to spread hatred," she wrote.

Chandra Kumar Bose, a sidelined BJP leader and grandnephew of Indian nationalist Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, tweeted that "This is the real heritage & culture of India. Certain religious bigots cannot digest it!"

Bollywood film producer, Priya Gupta, simply wrote "This is called dua," as a shut up call to all those maligning the respectful gesture.

This user condemned Islamophobia and said, "In fact you all are spitting venom out there. So stop!"

Following the backlash, Yadav tweeted that he had "just asked a question" and that "opponents of PM Modi did not appreciate his work in national interest".

It is absolutely absurd that some people will resort to twisting acts of respect to create controversy when there is none, even in such a sensitive time. This is a time to honour a legend, not ask foolish and pointed questions, trying to get people riled up. No one with an ounce of grey matter would spit during a funeral and for this BJP leader to even suggest it is beyond ridiculous.

Rather than spread bigotry with foolish questions, Mangeshkar's funeral and the two national days of mourning in India should be spent remembering the legendary singer and her major contributions to music in the subcontinent.

Mangeshkar was one of India's most beloved singers, her voice was the soundtrack to hundreds of Bollywood films. She'd sung in Hindi, Marathi, Bengali and other regional languages. She was honoured with the Bharat Ratna, Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Dadasaheb Phalke Award as well as several National and Filmfare Awards. Her extraordinary career spanned more than half a century and she recorded thousands of songs in 36 languages.

She is beloved in India as well as Pakistan and many other countries and she deserves far more respect than having foolish people on Twitter trying to spin controversy out of her well-wishers saying their final farewells at her funeral.

Comments

MG Feb 07, 2022 01:05pm
It is happening in India, keep cool
Recommend (0)
haider shaikh Feb 07, 2022 01:08pm
Hum Dua'a Parrhtay rahay, Wo Dagha samajhtay rahay. Ek nuktay nay Muharam ko Mujrim bana diya
Recommend (0)
Vijay B. Feb 07, 2022 01:13pm
Shah Rukh Khan did what he did as a gesture of goodwill and meant no harmor malice; and as broadminded as most Hindus are, they will pass it up as such, no harm done. But he should have known better. I ask you and shah Rukh khan "Would Muslims tolerate a Hindu doing a Hindu ritual over the body of a Muslim at his or her funeral?"
Recommend (0)
Mango Kashmiri, Srinagar Feb 07, 2022 01:13pm
BJP -RSS should be declared terrorist organization by UN . Their all politics revolves around Hindu -Muslim communally conflict creating issues .
Recommend (0)
ENGR Hamid shafiq Feb 07, 2022 01:14pm
Now India is not secular country better to change the constitution of India
Recommend (0)
Multani Feb 07, 2022 01:30pm
Political drama being played at this singers death, good point scoring by congress which I think will bring prosperity to all Indians by their secular values.
Recommend (0)
funnyman Feb 07, 2022 01:38pm
Madam Lata was a well-known steadfast BJP supporter who even sang BJP exclusive songs.
Recommend (0)
Manoj Patel Feb 07, 2022 02:07pm
Do not make a issue of this man. No BJP leader has said like this. There are some mad people on our side, as you have on your side can comment like this. Sharukh is a super star, he has immense respect in India. He a most loved guy and no one will believe this.
Recommend (0)
Sal Canada Feb 07, 2022 02:20pm
Looks like a deliberate and irresponsible Hindutva ploy to start an irrational, meaningless and senseless controversy.
Recommend (0)
Sakshi Feb 07, 2022 02:31pm
The message from BJP and Modi should be clear to all Muslims by now. Time for these 200 million to leave India including Bollywood stars.
Recommend (0)
Hope Feb 07, 2022 02:35pm
Removal of mask seem to have created this doubt..
Recommend (0)
Zak Feb 07, 2022 02:42pm
Arun Yadav, state-in-charge of BJP Haryana IT, posted a video on Twitter asking whether the actor had spit. This man needs to be in a mental asylum. He needs help like his boss Modi.
Recommend (0)
ABU TALIB Feb 07, 2022 02:42pm
On such a scenario Muslim should make certain distance.
Recommend (0)
Zak Feb 07, 2022 02:45pm
Following the backlash, Yadav tweeted that he had "just asked a question" and that "opponents of PM Modi did not appreciate his work in national interest". He should ask questions about his mental health?
Recommend (0)
Baloch Feb 07, 2022 02:50pm
Indians' tolerance is depreciating faster than their economy. It has become a laughing stock to the world. Even Afghanistan looks more sane country these days when compared to India.
Recommend (0)
KPK Booster Feb 07, 2022 02:52pm
New hindu goddess.
Recommend (0)
ZZQ Feb 07, 2022 02:54pm
Well... Cant blame Modi and his team mates... spreading hatred is their strategy to win election and stay relevant.
Recommend (0)
Jaredlee007 Feb 07, 2022 03:03pm
Shah Rukh Khan should have spat on BJP.
Recommend (0)
Sam Feb 07, 2022 03:05pm
Twisted mentality of BJP leaders is not a surprise for the silent world. We’ll done Congress!
Recommend (0)
Akbar Feb 07, 2022 03:17pm
They can't help it, can they?
Recommend (0)
Tanvir Khan Feb 07, 2022 03:18pm
Rumours and the morbid gullibility of humans are closely related!
Recommend (0)
NYS Feb 07, 2022 03:24pm
BJP can manipulate go at any length to distress Muslim faith
Recommend (0)
AJJU Feb 07, 2022 03:24pm
All good in the hood. Hindutva ideology will destroy Hindustan from the inside. No need for external enemies.
Recommend (0)
MD Feb 07, 2022 03:31pm
Pls take SRK to Pak. not needed in india
Recommend (0)
Saad Feb 07, 2022 03:34pm
@Vijay B. Could you please enlighten us How would a hindu pay his respect at a muslim funeral?? One only prays to his believed creator and as their faiths. The important thing is he prayed and shown a decent gesture to departed soul of Lata Jee.
Recommend (0)
aijaz gul Feb 07, 2022 03:47pm
"Phoonkna" is final part of dua. Prayers.RIP
Recommend (0)
TenJee Feb 07, 2022 03:48pm
According to most rulings, Muslims are not allowed to pray for non-Muslim deceased as that matter becomes closed. On attending a religious service or ritual of another religion, one should not visibly show ones own rituals as that could be seen as a mark of disrespect. He himself has declared he is comfortable with a dual Hindu/Muslim household, and so why did he do duaa when he would have been comfortable doing the Hindu rituals?
Recommend (0)
Soniye Tu Auder Te La Feb 07, 2022 04:06pm
Would Pakistan allow a Hindu to join a Muslim funeral, and take walk around the dead body to pay respect?
Recommend (0)
Taimur Feb 07, 2022 04:06pm
Many Indians do not like Shahrukh khan. There is a strong suspicion that he was propped up by underworld gangs & crime money. He should have just folded is hands like others. That would have been more appropriate.
Recommend (0)
Rubina Aleem Feb 07, 2022 04:07pm
@MD India is very much SRK's country as it is yours. What right you have to say this?
Recommend (0)
Arjun Feb 07, 2022 04:07pm
BJP has done more damage to India than ISI could even dream of
Recommend (0)
Anwar Feb 07, 2022 04:10pm
@Vijay B. that's a weird question if you're really broad-minded because liberal Muslims would totally respect Hindus saying their prayers the way they do it.
Recommend (0)
Anwar Feb 07, 2022 04:19pm
@MD What a shameless comment. A guy brings billions in revenue, name, and fame to the country and this is how you repay him just because you don't like his faith. smh
Recommend (0)
Raza Feb 07, 2022 04:26pm
@Vijay B. Everyone offers prayers by their own religion and beliefs not as per the dead.
Recommend (0)
THE Feb 07, 2022 04:36pm
Incredible India!
Recommend (0)
skumar Feb 07, 2022 04:38pm
SRK-the superstar is an icon and loved by millions and Lata ji is our bharat ratna ! One odd random stupid question by an ignoramus , cannot change the fact !
Recommend (0)
Truth be told Feb 07, 2022 05:03pm
So she will reincarnate in what form and where?
Recommend (0)
Truth be told Feb 07, 2022 05:05pm
@Vijay B. Which act or part of Shahrukh's life depicts he is a Muslim, other than his name?
Recommend (0)
Dr Dummy Feb 07, 2022 05:54pm
ALL BJP leaders are not worthy of being leaders. Simply ignore the rubbish. Period.
Recommend (0)
PakPig Feb 07, 2022 06:04pm
@Jaredlee007 Why not on your family!
Recommend (0)
PakPig Feb 07, 2022 06:07pm
@Zak So does your family.
Recommend (0)
Dr. Salaria, Aamir Ahmad Feb 07, 2022 06:12pm
Inna Lilla Hay Waa Inna Illehey Rajayoon.
Recommend (0)
Maria Rather Feb 07, 2022 06:22pm
@MD oh we will gladly take him. You have lost all respect by being so pathetic
Recommend (0)
Ibrahim S Feb 07, 2022 06:22pm
RSS and BJB is blinded with hate, and arrogance. Look what happened to your west when similar bigots started ruling that country .
Recommend (0)
Ibrahim S Feb 07, 2022 06:31pm
@Vijay B. You have a mindset of division .
Recommend (0)
Ali Mehdi Feb 07, 2022 06:41pm
What rubbish. How can a person from minority group in India put up with all this nonsense. It’s horrendous to even think of ever stepping in todays radicalized Hindu India
Recommend (0)
Simba Feb 07, 2022 06:41pm
Shah Rukh Khan's disgusting gesture for all to see especially in the era of Covid
Recommend (0)
Allan Feb 07, 2022 07:01pm
Let’s stop and think for a second how Madam Lata would think and feel about this. We all are too I grossed on ourselves. She would be too embarrassed by this entire situation so in a way the bigots of SRK are being totally disrespectful to Madam Lata.
Recommend (0)
Saleem Chisty Feb 07, 2022 07:06pm
he's created his own hybrid religion by mixing and matching the BJP wants him to choose one.
Recommend (0)
Allan Feb 07, 2022 07:08pm
@Ibrahim S Please keep your concentration to the East for now. Stay the course.
Recommend (0)
Schabboo Khan Feb 07, 2022 07:09pm
@Vijay B. Yes
Recommend (0)
Jawwad Feb 07, 2022 07:27pm
Indians are a laughing stock of the world.
Recommend (0)
Rohit Feb 07, 2022 07:33pm
@Vijay B. Please have some shame. What hindu Muslim is going on in my country I feel repelled by people like you ... srk gave the best he could have given to his mother ... bigotry has not limit
Recommend (0)
Saif Zulfiqar Feb 07, 2022 07:39pm
People of narrow minded Indians always make false accusations against Indian Muslim celebrities.
Recommend (0)
Danish Feb 07, 2022 07:40pm
Sharukh Khans prayed for her and just blow air after that, as it's a tradition to blow Air a sign of safety, we called it "phookna" no sign of spitting. But I believe it's time for King Khan to leave India, because it's hard to convince fools. Saf Ali Khan, Salaman Khan, Sharukh Khan are getting such threads once Modi came in Power. Indian Govt. neglecting minorities Rights, Human Rights. Asaddudin Owasi is attacked last time. They want these Film stars to work for India and create a name but they wouldn't recognized them as Indians.
Recommend (0)
Atta Feb 07, 2022 07:43pm
@Vijay B. No Muslims will not tolerate doing Hindu rituals at all ; SRK Just attended the ceremony paid tribute but he did not bury Lara ji same way when Dilip(Youssef Khan) and Thakeray came and paid tribute in Hindu way but didn’t cremate his body; open your mind and heart and don’t spew hatred
Recommend (0)
well-wisher Feb 07, 2022 07:44pm
RIP Lataji.
Recommend (0)
Afza Feb 07, 2022 07:49pm
Any person with a simple common sense will not utter this kind of nonsense that SRK "spit on Lata"!! Especially a person well-known not only in Bollywood but also the world over will not dare this act in public place. Count your grey cells - the number will not go beyond two!
Recommend (0)
Ibrahim S Feb 07, 2022 07:54pm
@MD - are you pushing out Muslims now as you pushed out Buddhists . Did you forget the loyalty of 500 years so soon .
Recommend (0)
LgbtqX Feb 07, 2022 08:08pm
@Manoj Patel ,really!!
Recommend (0)
Javed Feb 07, 2022 08:12pm
Islam doesn’t recognize marriage with people other than Jews & Christians. His ‘wife’ is Hindu.
Recommend (0)
Abdul Chaudhry Feb 07, 2022 08:18pm
I don't think he meant it, but it did appear that he spit.
Recommend (0)
Taimur Feb 07, 2022 08:21pm
I am from Pakistan. But I won't support such act. During these pandemic times, it is not advisable to remove mask and blow air from mouth even if is after dua.
Recommend (0)
TZaman Feb 07, 2022 08:22pm
Religious fanatics are same in their evilness. Nothing surprising.
Recommend (0)
Patriot Feb 07, 2022 08:26pm
India's constitution states that it is a secular country and all religions are welcome. But, this is a clear example of hatred towards the Muslims in India. It is extremely deplorable.
Recommend (0)
SSA Feb 07, 2022 08:27pm
Hindutva extremism will eventually ruin India, all the signs are there
Recommend (0)
N_Saq Feb 07, 2022 08:30pm
Why are Pakistanis defending? If Modi/BJP wants war then let it be an all out war.
Recommend (0)
Hamed Feb 07, 2022 08:54pm
@Vijay B. Yes. If he prays decently!
Recommend (0)
Fast comment Feb 07, 2022 09:38pm
He was simply blowing air after dua ( prayer).
Recommend (0)
Ashraf Feb 07, 2022 10:26pm
So much hatred on the basis of religion
Recommend (0)
Varoon Feb 07, 2022 11:11pm
@Sakshi Yes, they should leave. Good advice. We couldn't agree more
Recommend (0)
Varoon Feb 07, 2022 11:13pm
@Anwar He "didn't bring billions", he earned billions with our money
Recommend (0)
Ibrahim S Feb 08, 2022 02:35am
BJP and Modi has significantly lower down the bar of decency
Recommend (0)
pc amin Feb 08, 2022 02:52am
@Vijay B. yes why not. intention counts not the method
Recommend (0)
pc amin Feb 08, 2022 02:55am
@Sakshi why ? is india modi's jagir?
Recommend (0)
I love u Pakistan Feb 08, 2022 05:31am
@Sakshi it's their country, if someone does not like it, they can leave.
Recommend (0)
prince Feb 08, 2022 08:51am
person can blow air from mouth by keeping is head high, not keeping down..
Recommend (0)
Faraz Feb 08, 2022 01:13pm
@Anwar so who are the true Muslims liberal Muslims or fundamentalist Muslims and what do you mean by liberal Muslims ?
Recommend (0)
Sid C Feb 08, 2022 07:47pm
For people who don’t know what he was doing ,definitely looks like spitting for them.
Recommend (0)