Images

When will we tell our own stories, asks Yasir Hussain as Bollywood announces series on Lahore's Heera Mandi

When will we tell our own stories, asks Yasir Hussain as Bollywood announces series on Lahore's Heera Mandi

Netflix and Indian director Sanjay Leela Bhansali have teamed up for a series on Lahore's courtesans.
10 Aug, 2021

Indian director Sanjay Leela Bhansali is making a series on Lahore's infamous Heera Mandi for Netflix, it has been announced. The news may have created a stir in Bollywood, but for many Pakistani artists, it's a reminder of how we ignore our own stories.

Heera Mandi is a historical red-light district near the Lahore Fort. The district, whose name translates as “Diamond Market”, is close to the Badshahi Mosque.

During the Mughal era, Heera Mandi was a centre for mujra, traditional singing and dancing performed for the elites.

The tagline for the film, titled Heeramandi, is "where courtesans were queens". Bhansali, the brains behind Ram Leela, is known for the vibrant imagery and intricate details of his films and there is no doubt that the series will be visually appealing.

"This is in Lahore and the movie is being made by Indians," wrote actor Yasir Hussain in his Instagram Stories.

"Then we’ll say everything was portrayed incorrectly. I don’t know when we’ll talk about our own things, when we’ll tell our own stories," he wrote. It's easy to understand his frustration. There are so many stories to tell in Pakistan but more often than not, our entertainment industry focuses on stories that have already been told ad nauseam.

Comments

Hasan Aug 10, 2021 01:44pm
I think he jst woke up to the fact that Pakistan film industry is rock bottom for decades.
Recommend
Fastrack Aug 10, 2021 02:02pm
A fly always finds and sits on the proverbial. Enough said.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Aug 10, 2021 02:09pm
We will be able to write and produce quality films and plays on our own history when we will be morally strong to take the responsibility of our history on our own land. We do not own our history. How can we produce true art. Indians glorified their Umrao Jaan Ada . Can we write something about our own powerful women in past who were not a part of pseudo moralistic set up but had laid down foundations of art,culture and etiquette culture in civic life.
Recommend
Guds Aug 10, 2021 02:09pm
Lahore is the city of Prince Luv, the sob of Lord Ram. Very much part of India. Go back to your hibernation.
Recommend
Zak Aug 10, 2021 02:49pm
In india people are dropping dead, indian virus is rampant, bodies floating in rivers, yet their media is making film about heera mandi. Modi has his priorities twisted.
Recommend
M. Saeed Aug 10, 2021 02:58pm
In return, Pakistan should make such stories on Bhindi Bazar, which is the Heramandi of Bombay, now Mumbai.
Recommend
Sane Mind1st Aug 10, 2021 03:21pm
Let the Master works. We are novice with wasted actors.
Recommend
ST Aug 10, 2021 03:41pm
Heera mandi is not something to cherish upon.
Recommend
D’Souza Aug 10, 2021 04:30pm
This is set in pre independent india when Lahore was very much a part of india. Going by this man’s logic we shouldn’t make any movies on Bharat Singh because he was in Pakistani Punjab.
Recommend
Just Saying Aug 10, 2021 04:30pm
Courtesans also ruled during Gen. Yahya's tenure.
Recommend
Raman Kumar Aug 10, 2021 04:30pm
@Zak this shows your helpless attitude and frustration. A pure inferiority complex.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Aug 10, 2021 04:35pm
@Guds native culture is never hibernated in any oblivion. It stays . It can be shared but can not be broken.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Aug 10, 2021 04:36pm
@ST it is a part of history. As Umrao Jaan Ada is in history of Lucknow.
Recommend
Murad Mahal Aug 10, 2021 05:36pm
@Zak What Modi has to do with movie making. Are you sane?
Recommend
Rks Aug 10, 2021 05:40pm
What else there to narrate about Pakistan?
Recommend
riz Aug 10, 2021 05:43pm
why is this clown given so much coverage on here?
Recommend
Aalyar Aug 10, 2021 05:51pm
Don't Worry Yasir.. India is there to tell your story (of heera mandi) so you don't need to. You should be proud because your story is told by others...
Recommend
Badtameez Kudi Aug 10, 2021 05:53pm
For Pakistanis, their history starts from 1947, thanks to the 70-year long manipulation of the minds by their establishment. It's too late now.
Recommend
Pearl Aug 10, 2021 05:55pm
The series is set in Lahore of pre-independent India. BEFORE the Partition. Before Pakistan was created. So it's 100% story of Hindustan. Looking forward on Netflix India.
Recommend
Ali Mehdi Aug 10, 2021 06:08pm
So what. But they won’t cast you for sure.
Recommend
Kulbhushan Yadav Aug 10, 2021 06:09pm
Movie ka naam Pakistan hona chahiye tha. Pakistan= Heera Mandi.
Recommend
Dr Khan from Vancouver Aug 10, 2021 06:33pm
@Zak it cannot be everything with Modi, we have billion people with billion opportunities, and tons of sectors. People have freedom to what they want to do and business flourished everywhere. India is Center of art, culture which you have kill with religious zeal. Wake up.
Recommend
Ali Aug 10, 2021 06:36pm
@Chrís Dăn Indians portrayed Umrao as a victim of her circumstances and so did the Pakistanis. I believe the Pakistani production was much superior to the work that was produced in those times by both industries.
Recommend
Sal Aug 10, 2021 06:49pm
Pakistan rejects much of its own history and culture and that is why there is literally no movies or documentaries on it. The disguise of being arabs has choked all creativity and exploration of the past. Even the arabs of today are more modern and reject all Pakistani notion of having any connection with them.
Recommend
Sid Aug 10, 2021 06:55pm
Why don't you tell stories of Takshashila, Sharada Peeth, Lahorkar Lala Lajpatrai, Gorakhnath, Dayanand Saraswati?
Recommend
Ali da Malanga Aug 10, 2021 06:56pm
@Chrís Dăn - One of the biggest stories of the 19th century was the creation of Pakistan. Our political leaders of that time wrote that story and executed it with the help of our elders. It was very different from the world wars of that time because we were not trying to invade or occupy anyone. Based on your definition, even the US doesn't have a history because that land was once under the native's control.
Recommend
Ajaz Aug 10, 2021 07:23pm
Actually, we did'nt have our own stories.
Recommend
ST Aug 10, 2021 07:32pm
@Chrís Dăn sorry we better stay away from such history which is nothing but embarrassment. Lets cherish the history of all those muslim leaders and intellectuals who governed the world.
Recommend
Ali Mehdi Aug 10, 2021 07:40pm
@Sid arei bhai is we Pakistanis start celebrating heroes from other faiths we will be killed by mob because we will be seen as committing blasphemy. Better not to give us such useless advices.
Recommend
Ali Mehdi Aug 10, 2021 07:52pm
We understand it is yasir’s story n he wants to narrate it himself. What better option than to have it straight from horse’s mouth.
Recommend
planettrekker Aug 10, 2021 07:53pm
But I thought Pakistani history (the revised version based on outright denial) was now linked with the Arabs. So why the outcry?
Recommend
AbuBakr Mela Aug 10, 2021 08:31pm
Time is ripe for Pakistan’s complete demolition as a superstar of hypocrisy, shamelessness and moral and financial Bankruptcy
Recommend
M khan Aug 10, 2021 08:34pm
Have you looked at the quality of Pakistani material.? We are at least 20 years behind compared to India.
Recommend
Vish Aug 10, 2021 10:16pm
Pakistan film industry should make movies on Arabs, Turks and Chinese.
Recommend
Malik Aug 10, 2021 10:17pm
The name India also came from Pakistan alone with all the history of present Indians
Recommend
Malik Aug 10, 2021 10:32pm
Indians believe their origin is in Pakistan due to Indus Valley civilization and Aryan settlements.
Recommend
Shezi Aug 10, 2021 11:09pm
Well, they no doubt portray it incorrectly. It's a Truth. After all they are Indians.
Recommend
Chacha Aug 10, 2021 11:36pm
Is Hera Mandi a art or history? Not for us, for Indians may be
Recommend
Ali Mehdi Aug 11, 2021 01:39am
Our media industry is very inclusive. It also allows people even with the autistic looks to be a part of it.
Recommend
Observer Aug 11, 2021 01:40am
Indus valley gave India its name so nothing surprising that a story of Lahore comes from Bollywood. After all Pakistan was India once.
Recommend
Omar Aug 11, 2021 02:59am
This guy has zero talent yet chronic complainer.
Recommend
Syed Aug 11, 2021 03:00am
Who is he?
Recommend
HumanA Aug 11, 2021 03:03am
Nobody has stopped any Pakistani including those complaining from making a drama or a movie on the red light district. In fact, it has been down to varying degrees in various Pakistani dramas. Those complaining should've thought about it earlier.
Recommend
kashif ajaz Aug 11, 2021 07:20am
Why don't you start doing it?
Recommend
Bwana Quba Aug 11, 2021 07:51am
Pakistanis are not that talented
Recommend
Frank Manuel Aug 11, 2021 09:00am
Sex is Taboo in Pakistan culture. So several topics portraying women are out of bounds. So can’t blame the movie industry. Of course the public will ogle the movie made by Bollywood.
Recommend
ali Aug 11, 2021 09:27am
when you won't tell your own story someone will...
Recommend
Zafar Yousufzai Aug 11, 2021 09:52am
In fact, we don't try the historical issues on celluloid rather than copy others. Don't blame 'courage' it's all about creativity and enthusiasm that is fading out from our nationalism. we're the old-fashioned followers and NOT leaders. Take an example of Ertughral - this is an example to bring history to the small screen. Heera Mundi is a test for Bollywood bad boys. I guarantee they are not going to depict a true picture of Heera Mundi but to insult our culture and heritage. They made several movies against Pakistan and readers are witnesses who have seen what they targeted nothing but the Muslim nation and country at large.
Recommend
Reality bites Aug 11, 2021 10:56am
@Rks Clear your thought, the movie is of pre partition era, so nothing do with the current Pakistan.
Recommend
Reality bites Aug 11, 2021 10:57am
@Kulbhushan Yadav Such Nothing more than the hate, hope one day you will settle down and feel remorse.
Recommend
NSG Aug 11, 2021 10:58am
@Zafar Yousufzai what is your culture?
Recommend
ambreen Aug 12, 2021 07:03am
Would Pakistani movie makers make a movie on Heera mandi ? Awam would be out on streets so let them make it, no big deal.
Recommend
Zahid Hussain Hussain Aug 14, 2021 08:58am
No doubts useless bums become actors or ballerinas, he should read history of Pk.art and culture
Recommend