Images

Pakistani Twitter slams web-series Dhoop Ki Deewar for being 'unpatriotic' before it has even been aired

Pakistani Twitter slams web-series Dhoop Ki Deewar for being 'unpatriotic' before it has even been aired

They claim it is "anti-Pakistan", "anti-Kashmir" and "anti-two-nation theory". All that from just a trailer.
Updated 19 Jun, 2021

Pakistani web-series Dhoop Ki Deewar recently released its trailer on YouTube. The series tells the tale of romance between an Indian boy and a Pakistani girl whose fathers were rival soldiers and martyred in Kashmir. Many Pakistanis are unhappy with the plot and some have even called for it to be banned, even though writer Umera Ahmed confirmed that the script was given the green light by the ISPR.

The show will air on Indian streaming platform Zee 5 on June 25 and stars off screen couple Sajal Aly and Ahad Raza Mir. Zee 5 is the same platform that gave us Churails.

The outcry prompted a response from the writer, novelist Umera Ahmed. “I am thankful to all of you for supporting my principled stance, that it is the basic right of a writer to initiate debate on any important matter in their work,” she wrote in a statement shared on Facebook.

She clarified that the story is her own creation, one that she started writing as a novel in 2018 and owns the IP rights to. She also revealed that she was hired by Pakistani firm Group M to make the story into a drama. The show was then produced in association with Haseeb Hasan’s production house Hamdan Films. “All the production of the show was handled by Group M,” she said.

“If this project is good, the entirety of the credit goes to me and Group M. Even if it is bad, the responsibility falls entirely on us.”

In a later post, she addressed all the criticism she received individually.

"When I started working on Dhoop Ki Deewar in 2019, I sent the story to the Inter-Services Public Relations,” she told us. “I asked the team for its evaluation so that I would edit out anything objectionable in the story.”

One of the things being criticised in the show — which hasn't even been aired yet — is that it is "selling the blood of Kashmiris" by showing rival soldiers' children falling in love. Critics say the idea of these two fictional people falling in love undermines the Kashmir struggle. They also don't appreciate Pakistani creators selling their work to Indian platforms.

BanDhoopKiDeewar quickly became a trend on Twitter.

People seemed to believe that the show — which we must repeat has not aired yet — challenges the two-nation theory.

Others felt that promoting good relations with our neighbouring country was not acceptable and that the only viable relationship was "revenge for hatred".

Others cried "shame" at the supposed "anti state and Kashmir narrative" in the show.

Some people called out the actors for becoming part of "5th generation warfare for money".

Others believe the show is supportive of Indian atrocities in occupied Kashmir.

However, supporters of the show are also active online.

One thing we have learned, however, from Pakistani outrage at films or TV shows that have not even been aired is that the public sees what it wants to. The writer of Dhoop Ki Dewar and supporters are urging people to wait and watch it before making their judgements and we would urge the same. Wait to see the show before cancelling it for being pro-India.

Comments

GM Jun 19, 2021 05:10pm
In fact sufferings of Indian and Pakistani people are same. United we can stand and divided we shall fall. Only establishments of both countries have problems for their vested interest. Otherwise how Hindus could have stayed in Pakistan and vice versa. Problem lies in Government ill policies and among long boots. Please digest this truth.
Recommend
Fastrack Jun 19, 2021 05:19pm
Reality is the opposite. India just passed shameless laws to stop increasing trend of Hindu girls marrying Muslim men.
Recommend
Ifti Malik Jun 19, 2021 05:21pm
Just goes to show far brainwashed both Pakistani and Indian youth are , today . In our times, we could still get historical and current affairs views (1950s-1960s) that were balanced and objective. We fought the 1965 war but Indians and Pakistanis could still like each other and respect each other as human beings , without falling for official military propaganda on either side . Today , it's pathetic to see how the inimical and narrow-minded narratives on both sides of the border have become. The Indo-Pakistani divide has become a gulf and it's doubtful this will ever be surmounted . Sane people and sincere efforts seeking regional peace, will be increasingly marginalised here and there . Alas .
Recommend
Imran Qureshi Jun 19, 2021 05:51pm
How come Ehd e wafa super patriotic hero Ehd raza mir became son of martyred indian army officer look like many people in ISPR need Karmina to digest it. Kashmir can be part of pakistan pakistanis can support kashmir and kashmiris but please avoid naunsense pakistan and pakistanis are not kashmir or kashmiris..over and out!
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 19, 2021 06:37pm
Love does not ask questions about geographical boundaries,religion,cultureetc. Love is an experience felt by soul. The topic is fine and I am looking forward to see it.
Recommend
Truth be told Jun 19, 2021 07:13pm
If the Indian boy in the plot is a Hindu then shame on this anti-Islamic plot. If the writer thinks that she can embark on forbidden themes and get famous then she is making a big mistake and digging a hole for herself and the misguided youth. Evil needs to be nipped in the bud, no matter what people say. Once it grows roots then hell breaks lose. Take the example of PTI. Everyone was warned. Similarly with this concept taking roots, cross religion romances will prevail and will lead to such a distorted social fabric that our next generations will regret why we even used media as a form of expression. Foresee the future and stop ruining everything just to make a few bucks. May be the series will twist towards the end and that's why was approved by some agency but the current suspense makes thoughts hit the peaks which are forbidden. Don't take it lightly.
Recommend
Truth be told Jun 19, 2021 07:14pm
@Ifti Malik can you rewrite in one sentence what you are aiming to state?
Recommend
Truth be told Jun 19, 2021 07:15pm
@Chrís Dăn Never ever have I seen any comment that in the long run will safeguard our roots, culture and religion. Modernization doesn't imply that one breaks taboos. One can become modern and in fact stay ahead of everyone without crossing limits. Hope this will help.
Recommend
M. Saeed Jun 19, 2021 07:30pm
On the contrary, it is a message that we still recognise the fact that, all 625+ million Muslims of Sub-continent (Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and others overseas) were not imported refugees, but born and bred in the same common ground for thousands of years, to become on their free will, what they are today and must unite again against the wishes of those, who want the sub-continent to remain low and not to progress to rival them. They can never forget that, they discovered what is their First World, in default, in their greedy search to discover a Western route to the Sub-Continent.
Recommend
Ibrahim Jun 19, 2021 07:47pm
A response to a hate should not be hate . If you do , your play in their hands
Recommend
Observer Jun 19, 2021 09:17pm
Whatever brings people together is good, whatever divides them is not.
Recommend
Abbasshah Jun 19, 2021 09:36pm
Just watch them how they live together in foreign lands.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 19, 2021 10:03pm
@Truth be told but Love is a soul experience,beyond every religion.
Recommend
Anuj Sethi Jun 19, 2021 10:03pm
@Fastrack which law just tell me instead of propaganda u should read about facts
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 19, 2021 10:08pm
@Truth be told modern?Love is an ancient most reality which purely deals with our bondage of soul to soul. Love is a heavenly feeling was born before any religion was born on earth. Hence it is an ultimate reality on universe since time infinite. It is ancient therefore it has no taboos etc as all theologies,taboos came later.
Recommend
Ahmed Jun 19, 2021 10:24pm
Some people have a vested interest in keeping the pot boiling between India and Pakistan. Until we learn to listen to differing views nothing will change.
Recommend
Fastrack Jun 19, 2021 10:47pm
Spiritual writer Umera Ahmed. Patriotic army officer role doer Ahad Raza. ناحق کے لیے اٹھے تو شمشیر بھی فتنہ شمشیر تو کیا نعرہ تکبیر بھی فتنہ (اقبال)
Recommend
Moazzam Jun 19, 2021 11:07pm
If it is really a good webseries then why it is airing on Indian channel Pakistani channels have died?
Recommend
Zak Jun 19, 2021 11:49pm
Stop mixing Indian and Pakistani into relationships. Pakistan is Pakistan and India is India and never shall the twain meet.
Recommend
Hussain Jun 20, 2021 12:01am
And they're absolutely correct. From the trailer, it appears this drama tries to "humanise" the Indian occupation forces in Kashmir. Its a disgrace. Nothing - absolutely nothing - can justify Indian terrorism in IOK. And they called Kashmiri freedom fighters "terrorists". The Indians are the ones causing the suffering in Kashmir - they aren't the victims, in any sense of the word.
Recommend
John Jun 20, 2021 12:18am
It is a complete brainwashing of the youth of the country regarding two nation concept of 1947 division.According to writer there is no difference between the two absolutly opposite codes of ethics.The writer has straight forwardly supported & favoured,the enemies of the state,by showing the 1947 partition as nonsense, demonstrating no knowledge of extremly prejudice laws of hindus,marring a muslim person.
Recommend
Zak Jun 20, 2021 12:43am
The outcry prompted a response from the writer, novelist Umera Ahmed. “I am thankful to all of you for supporting my principled stance, that it is the basic right of a writer to initiate debate on any important matter in their work,” she wrote This is not debate but insulting the nation and everything it stands for just to please India, hence the showing on zee TV which as everyone knows is linked to a sinister Organisation.
Recommend
Zak Jun 20, 2021 12:44am
@GM Forst apply that to Kashmiris suffering oppression and brutal occupation in IOK. Don't be hypocritical.
Recommend
Zak Jun 20, 2021 12:46am
@Ifti Malik Ever tried telling that to Kashmiris in IOK as to how much Indians like them, that their gift has been mass Graves, detention murder, rapes, maiming and disappearances,imcluding of children as young as 8. Have some compassion for IOK.
Recommend
Uddin Jun 20, 2021 01:11am
There are millions of Muslim living in India , why the guy has to be Hindu? Is that the writers fantasy or something?
Recommend
Aisha Khan Jun 20, 2021 01:25am
Overrated writer.
Recommend
Annie Jun 20, 2021 01:35am
We have long been held hostage because of Kashmir. No more.
Recommend
Venkat Jun 20, 2021 05:18am
@Fastrack be sensitive.
Recommend
Marquis de Sade Jun 20, 2021 07:19am
To me, two people from opposing - or even warring - countries falling in love is not shocking. That someone would want to take it as a subject for a story for a TV show isn't shocking. That a plot/script has to be "approved" by a wing of the armed forces is extremely shocking.
Recommend
Saleem Jun 20, 2021 09:50am
The male character should have been an Indian Muslim or at least a Hindu who converted to Islam. That would be more palatable to Pakistani audiences. The producers and screen writers should have done basic research on their target market.
Recommend
vin Jun 20, 2021 10:21am
@Fastrack Which laws were passed? So how many Muslim girls getting married to Hindu men in Pakistan?
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 20, 2021 10:54am
@John but two nation theory failed in 1971 when East Pakistan opted to be an independent country.
Recommend
Amen Jun 20, 2021 11:16am
Art and freedom of expression is a myth in Islamic Republic of pakistan. But hypocrisy is a lifeline
Recommend
haid Jun 20, 2021 01:00pm
@Saleem the theme of the story is that love know no border , reliegon or race
Recommend
Umair Jun 20, 2021 02:30pm
I wonder if they would still be bashing it if the Girl was Indian and Boy was Pakistani..
Recommend
Truth be told Jun 20, 2021 02:48pm
@Chrís Dăn it's a test. Not sure what you mean by love existing before any religion but promoting forbidden love will eventually lead to legalizing beastiality and incest. Tread with caution.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 20, 2021 03:18pm
@Truth be told Love is love. The whole universe is interlinked in a bond which connects all and it happened before emergence of any formal theology. Love has different forms -one is love shared between human being and since ancient times love and effection are gifts of soul hence above any later designed parameters. You can not judge love. Judge hatred as it s forbidden in ethics.
Recommend
Chrís Dăn Jun 20, 2021 03:19pm
@haid and an infinite truth.
Recommend
Faisal Jun 20, 2021 10:24pm
@Zak quoting Shakespeare doesn't make your comment less dumb
Recommend
Sam Jun 20, 2021 11:20pm
Even Indians in their movies etc. always show Muslim Boy and a Hindu or other girl but never the opposite and these producers - what are they doing? Or the boy is a Muslim but belongs to India?
Recommend
Rp Jun 20, 2021 11:32pm
@Fastrack - Read the comment below by 'Truth be told' and you might get enlightened how Pakistani's view a Muslim girl marrying a Hindu boy. I'm sure you have the same views-just stronger; then why blame the laws that come from the other side.
Recommend
Talha Qureshi Jun 21, 2021 01:23am
An Indian channel bought this drama for a reason. Why are we so naive as a nation to understand this? This drama must not be aired at any cost. Let it be a lesson for those who intend to ignore inner voice of nation and woes of Kashmiris.
Recommend
Akil Akhtar Jun 21, 2021 04:48am
If it is being played on indian channels then it must be slanted against Pakistan....sadly our writers suffer from inferiority complex....
Recommend
Akil Akhtar Jun 21, 2021 04:52am
This is part fo the brainwashing of Pakistanis to accept hindus marrying a muslim girl which is against our religion...shame on such writers who seem to sell their pen....
Recommend
Zak Jun 21, 2021 03:37pm
Ban this anti state drama.
Recommend