Ra One director wants more of Bollywood to speak up about the CAA

Ra One director wants more of Bollywood to speak up about the CAA

Filmmaker Anubhav Singh also spoke on the three Khans and their silence over current matters.
26 Dec, 2019

One of Bollywood’s leading directors called on three superstar actors to break their silence about a new citizenship law that has triggered riots in India, saying they could influence millions of fans.

At least 21 people have died since crowds took to the streets enraged by the Hindu nationalist-led government’s legislation, which critics say discriminates against Muslims.

The violence and the political storm raging around it has posed a dilemma for a film industry that is dominated by Muslim actors, directors and crew but caters for India’s broader, predominantly Hindu population.

A handful of figures have spoken out against the law and the violence, some at rallies in Mumbai, the heart of Bollywood. But none of its three leading stars - Aamir Khan, Salman Khan and Shah Rukh Khan - have made public statements. All three are Muslim.

“These three actors and their fan following is something else. One word from them can influence millions,” director Anubhav Sinha, a critic of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, told Reuters.

“I... understand why they may not be able to speak out. I am not angry at them” said Sinha, who directed Shah Rukh Khan in the 2011 film Ra One.

He said it did not matter what they said about the law or the violence, just that they contributed to the debate. “I am not saying they should agree with me or others. Their opinion can be the opposite of what we have.”

None of the three Khans, who are not related, responded to Reuters requests for comment.

Industry insiders say the lack of comments or condemnations by some of the industry’s biggest names points to a broad cultural difference from Hollywood - where actors regularly take up political causes and criticize the government.

“In America, (President Donald) Trump cannot use the government machinery to go after actors who disagree with him, but here, that fear is very much there,” film critic and journalist Rajeev Masand told Reuters.

Modi has regularly appeared alongside actors and film industry figures at public events. The industry has, in turn, produced films that some critics have said approached political endorsements.

Three movies have appeared this year with lead actors in prime ministerial roles, including a biopic titled PM Narendra Modi.

Actress Sayani Gupta - who appeared with Shah Rukh Khan in his 2015 film Fan - last week retweeted a selfie that popular young actors including Ranveer Singh and Alia Bhatt took with Modi at an event. She added the message: “The time has come to speak up guys.”

A representative for Ranveer Singh said he was not available for comment while Bhatt’s spokeswoman did not immediately respond.

For protesters, especially those at Jamia Millia University in New Delhi, where Shah Rukh Khan was enrolled in his youth, his silence feels like a betrayal.

“Someone like him staying silent is unacceptable,” said literature student Zoya Nadeem Azmi.


ABCD Dec 26, 2019 01:49pm
Only few opposition parties like INC, TMC and one enemy country are against it . Others are in favour.
Imtiaz Ali Khan Dec 26, 2019 02:03pm
Be brave strong honest decision always go against the wind. Love the King Khans of Bollywood.
AJ Dec 26, 2019 02:32pm
Don't blame the Khans. Their bread and butter (and life) will be taken away if they even hint at the criticism of the new citizenship bill.
karr Dec 26, 2019 06:41pm
1000s of Indians are protesting against discrimination and for Secular and democratic values. They are protesting for the minorities.
Khalis Khan Dec 26, 2019 09:09pm
I am with you.
Ash20 Dec 27, 2019 02:40am
Why they should speak against the new law? Many may support the law then these activists will be talking against those actors. More than 1000 imminent personalities has published open letter supporting the new law whose purpose is to save some from religious prosecution.
Jimmy. Dec 27, 2019 08:57pm
@ABCD. 21 dead and counting suggets otherwise.
Jimmy. Dec 27, 2019 09:00pm
@Ash20 People look up to these Khans not because they have Muslim names, but because they are from secular backgrounds. Their silence indeed feels like a betrayal.