Images

Jab Harry Met Sejal review: A woman looks for a ring and a plot purpose

Jab Harry Met Sejal review: A woman looks for a ring and a plot purpose

For the amount it would have cost for travel, stay, food and party, Sejal may as well have just bought a new ring
06 Aug, 2017

Imtiaz Ali depends on metaphors and uses travel as a device to open up trapped emotions and desires.

But these ideas, which were strongly explored in Jab We Met, Rockstar and Highway, are too superficially addressed in Jab Harry Met Sejal, a 143-minute tour of Europe, which is 100 minutes too long.

Writer-director Ali’s idea of a girl finding herself while searching for her missing engagement ring in the company of a womanising tour guide is a slim premise. As they retrace their steps traversing Europe from Amsterdam to Prague to Budapest and Lisbon, their search for one thing, but obviously, leads to the discovery of the unexpected. No points for guessing that somewhere between the canals of Amsterdam, the arches of Prague’s Charles Bridge and Budapest’s terrace cafés, Harry and Sejal don’t just find each other, they also encounter their own true selves.

Logic is totally cast aside here. Sejal abruptly leaves her family and embarks on a retrieval trip around Europe, in the solitary company of a virtual stranger, Harry. Her family seems okay with this plan, and this wastefulness. For the amount it would have cost for travel, stay, food, partying etc, Sejal may as well have just bought a new ring.

Harry is a lonely man. He finds comfort in meaningless one-night stands. He’s the modern day equivalent of the proverbial ship that passes in the night, never dropping anchor for long. Sejal, for all the conservatism you might expect of a Gujarati girl about to have an arranged marriage, is rather self-confident. What’s disappointing though is that what she seems to seek is acknowledgement, not of her beauty or brains (sister-type) but her sexiness (one night stand material). Her half-hearted search for an heirloom ring is also a full-hearted pre-marriage honeymoon.

Besides one scene with Harry’s tour group colleague Mayank (Aru Krishansh Verma), the only actors you see throughout the first half are Shah Rukh Khan and Anushka Sharma who prattle on about nothing at all. Several scenes are airy and silly, such as one scene in a Prague nightclub from where Harry and Sejal have to flee. Considering the sketchy story – looking for this ring – it needn’t have taken as long as it does to get to the expected end.

The relationship between Harry and Sejal also gets a bit creepy, as one between an older man and a young woman would. It’s particularly off-putting when Sejal suggests that until the ring is found, Harry should pretend she is his girlfriend. And the next thing you know they are – platonically of course – sharing a queen size bed and singing songs on medieval balustrades.

Usually an Ali film scores on music, but here the songs are unable to touch a chord or find the soul of this film, perhaps because that’s the very thing that is absent from this story. What’s also missing from the screen is tingling, crackling chemistry between the leads because a largely two-hander, that follows a burgeoning attraction and self-discovery, needed fireworks.

While Khan does his best to reignite the magic of the romantic hero he so finely defined in the 90s, Harry is no Raj or Rahul. He certainly has his moments, as does Sharma with both being far more effective in the humorous and cutesy moments.

KU Mohanan’s cinematography, Aki Narula’s costumes and breathtaking European locales can only do so much. If the baseline for Jab Harry Met Sejal is ‘what you seek is seeking you’, then it’s time for Imtiaz Ali to seek a new canvas, because the idea of characters travelling in order to find answers within themselves seems to be suffering from acute jetlag.


This article, originally published at Scroll.in, has been reproduced with permission.

Comments

surya Aug 06, 2017 02:59pm
so right..
Recommend
Ahmad Kainth Aug 06, 2017 04:01pm
It's high time Shahrukh needed to understand that time has passed when his romantic charm could attract the audience . He has failed once again in making movie that may attract audience. No story, no effective music , no charm of seeing him in romantic avatar. He has to introspect as to why his movies have been flopped in recent past.
Recommend
Shrirang, navi Mumbai Aug 06, 2017 05:32pm
Flop movie, anushka was poor performer. Plot, story, dialogue were hopeless.
Recommend
Rana Aug 06, 2017 06:26pm
Do this guy know any other role playing. Totally spent .
Recommend
chenab Aug 06, 2017 06:57pm
very well written review.
Recommend
Kanwal Aug 07, 2017 03:07am
A mirror reflection of my thought indeed. I found sejal much more characterless than Harry himself lolz. I dont know what she was looking for. A playboy like harry gave her a genuine opinion any girl could have that you are pure no ome can pass a naughty look to you and she found it insulting to her body... Woooh I guess the mindset of sejal was completely offtrack . I believe she brought up the legal paper to sign preplanned so that she can have her as a bf in her prehoneymoon trip. It was sejal's agreement actually to touch her and she wont sue ROFL..It would have been "When old harry met despo sejal"
Recommend
AdNan Aug 07, 2017 05:46am
Totally agreed....utterly nonsense plot. Sheer waste of 143 minutes and 120 dirhams.
Recommend
Bhujang Patil Aug 07, 2017 06:20am
It was sad to see the lethargic performance of Shahrukh Khan in this zero entertainment flic.
Recommend
Abdulhaque Shaikh Aug 07, 2017 08:20am
Imtiaz Ali is bad story teller. He has wasted talents of Shahrukh and Anushka on bad script, bad jokes and over all bad direction. The movie is not watchable even with excellent screen presence of Shahrukh and Anushka
Recommend
Happy Aug 07, 2017 08:57am
So much "Lord of the rings" :)
Recommend
Farhan Pandit Aug 07, 2017 09:37am
A boring movie with not much of a story - recommended only for die hard shahrukh fans.
Recommend
khan Aug 07, 2017 10:00am
true..no real story line, same tea in new cup...
Recommend
khan Aug 07, 2017 10:01am
@AdNan better would have send this money to some deserving in Pakistan..
Recommend
khan Aug 07, 2017 10:02am
@Farhan Pandit all die hard fans are either dead or old enough to travel to cinema:)
Recommend
Alanore Aug 07, 2017 12:03pm
I saw this movie over the weekend, I am sorry it was very bad. They invest so much money but no story line. I am very disappointed in SRK all his movies were crap since Happy New Year with Depika
Recommend
optimistic pk Aug 07, 2017 03:24pm
time has come to get out of SRK's fever.
Recommend
AAMER Aug 07, 2017 04:26pm
After Chennai Express, all SRK movies failed to impress. Even in chennai express Depika stole the show. Salman touched the publics hearts when he did roles like Bagrangi Bhaijaan, Dabung and Sultan. Similarly Aamir Khans performance was very strong in PK and Dangle. I must say SRK didnt come up with anything different of strong after Devdas. He is very boring now.
Recommend
Ahmad Aug 07, 2017 06:28pm
SRK does not even bother changing his looks in any movie, looks like he wakes up and goes shooting, Im a fan of him but this broke my heart to see him giving flop after flop.
Recommend
Tango Tango Aug 08, 2017 12:45pm
He was never a good a good actor, a charmer yes, but not good at real acting. He is a smart brand manager and if his ego still lets his brain do the thinking, the best strategy at this stage for him would be to do silly slapstick comedy roles where he could make the audiences laugh to his stupidity and overacting. And then settle down to doing older roles like Amitabh and gracefully fade into the senior actor category. Otherwise a few more flops and he would completely loose his heard earned image.
Recommend
Kunal majumdar Aug 09, 2017 09:36am
Anushka Sharma lost her ring. Imtiaz Ali lost the script. Shah Rukh lost his reputation. Public lost money. Wish they never met.
Recommend