Images

Irrfan Khan criticises Islamic practises, Muslim clerics respond

Irrfan Khan criticises Islamic practises, Muslim clerics respond

Turns out the actor doesn't know the difference between Eid ul Azha and Muharram
Updated 01 Jul, 2016

Bollywood actor Irrfan Khan has landed himself in the midst of controversy after his criticism of some Islamic practices hurt religious sentiments.

According to India Today, the actor was in Jaipur for the promotion of his upcoming film Madaari when he criticised the practice of Ramazan and Muharram, a month of mourning observed largely by the Shiite community.

"Rather than fasting during Ramazan, people should self-introspect. Animals are being slaughtered [in] the name of qurbaani during Muharram. We, Muslims, have made a mockery of Muharram. It is meant for mourning and what [do] we do? Take out (tajiya) processions," he said.

Irrfan probably didn't understand that the practive of qurbaani -- the sacrifice of animals -- occurs on Eid ul Azha, and not Muharram.

The actor added that the meaning of Qurbani is to sacrifice something which is "close to you instead of any goat or sheep which you just buy to sacrifice. Before sacrificing we should share a bond with that thing otherwise just killing of an animal will not serve the purpose."

"Nowadays we have lost the relevance behind such religious activities and perform these rituals without knowing the meaning behind them,” Khan was quoted by Deccan Herald.

The actor also went on to pinpoint the issue of terrorism and asked Muslims to take up the issue with the higher authorities.

"Why Muslims are silent against the issue of terrorism? People should also question the politicians over this issue," he said.

In response to the criticism, Jaipur's Muslim cleric Maulana Abdul Wahid Khatri, state secretary of Jamaat-e-Ulema-e-Hind, asked the actor to focus on his career instead of the religious affairs of Muslims.

"It would be better if he concentrates on his film career and not make random statements about our religion. He is doing this just for the publicity of his upcoming movie," said Maulana Khatri.

Sher Qazi Khalid Usmani, Jaipur's Shaher Qazi (chief jurist) said, "He should keep his mouth shut as he has no knowledge about the religion."

Comments

Iqbal bhai Jul 01, 2016 12:00pm
Irfan Bhai --- that was a very loose ball from your side. Logically speaking, you should speak about a subject that you know well.
Recommend
Khanq Jul 01, 2016 12:02pm
Irfan khan please keep your business and Islamic views separate and just focus on your acting.
Recommend
MUSLIM RAJANI Jul 01, 2016 12:10pm
Boycott his movies...simple
Recommend
Rashid Sultan Jul 01, 2016 12:17pm
it is his democratic right.
Recommend
xpakistani Jul 01, 2016 12:22pm
That Qurbaani is food anyway, and nothing is wasted. A little more than normal amount of Halal meat is available to many more, mostly poorer people who would not get this food otherwise. And this is done on Eid Ul Azha and not Muharram. Please think before you speak Irfan Bhai.
Recommend
ahmed Jul 01, 2016 12:55pm
I like his acting style but I am really disappointed about his less informed remarks on religion.
Recommend
Muhammad Jul 01, 2016 12:56pm
Irffan Khan said kurbaani is giving away something close to you not animals. Roza means introspection not fasting. Muharram mean month of mourning not celebrating.
Recommend
Dervaish Khan Jul 01, 2016 12:57pm
Correctly said by Sher Qazi Khalid Usmani: "He should keep his mouth shut as he has no knowledge about the religion."
Recommend
Naqad Jul 01, 2016 12:59pm
In order to succeed in Bollywood he is trying to be politically correct by compromising his faith!
Recommend
Umar khan Jul 01, 2016 12:59pm
Qurbani in Muharram ? Definitely he has no understanding of Islamic month . Muharram is holy month because of our beloved Hazrat Hussain (ra).
Recommend
Bilal Hussain Jul 01, 2016 01:03pm
I am really disappointed by his remarks. He will lose his fan following.
Recommend
Patrick Jul 01, 2016 01:07pm
@Khanq Religion is a matter that should be private as in the west
Recommend
nnnn Jul 01, 2016 01:09pm
buddy try to be a good actor instead of explaining the things which you don't understand
Recommend
M Jul 01, 2016 01:12pm
Liberal values
Recommend
dp Jul 01, 2016 01:15pm
what he said is absolutely correct. there is only rituals left and no values. People boast of buying a Sheep for 5-10K and sacrficiing it (just show-off) but sidestep while giving a needy. other ppl in community are forced to take loans (udhar) for Eid, so they can also buy a coastly shep/goat and seen as equal in society. very wrong !
Recommend
Ashish Jul 01, 2016 01:17pm
There is no harm in doing introspection.
Recommend
mkb Jul 01, 2016 01:28pm
He has every right to place his views regarding some practice in Islam - because he himself is a Muslim by faith.
Recommend
Fawad ali Fawad Jul 01, 2016 01:35pm
unfortunately Mr Irfan you do not have religious knowledge that Muharram is not for Qurbani, you spoken bcs you have lack of information, keep shut mouth that is matter than nonsense and sensitive matter bring in the Holy month of Ramazan.
Recommend
Tauseef Jul 01, 2016 01:38pm
So when Moulvi say "our religion" means Islam only own by Moulvis. He is also Muslim and entitled of his opinion. He actually said the truth. Instead of Mufti sahab rectify the situation he's nullifying. In this situation, mufti showed how ignorant our society has became and that's exactly what he meant. (People sometime get confuse with Muharram and Eid, they are literally 18 days apart). Purely my opinion.
Recommend
Sami Jul 01, 2016 02:03pm
The advice to the actor is quite sensible. He should have to concentrate his energy to his profession. But being an Indian Muslim , Irfan khan is concerned with the plights of the Indian Muslims and wish to see them now in the mainstream of the Indian society. We cannot deny that the Indian Muslims are patriotic to their country. The intention of irfan khan was good and must be appreciated.
Recommend
Sami Jul 01, 2016 02:08pm
@Khanq kindly advice our politicians and mullahs as well to concentrate to their professions only rather to make fuss of religion at one side and politics on the other
Recommend
Naxalite Jul 01, 2016 02:57pm
You are promoting your product while being controversial? This guy is confused!
Recommend
Had Jul 01, 2016 03:13pm
@dp lol... if they have to get loans, they dont really need to buy the goat/sheep. Religously they would be exempt.
Recommend
Shahwani Jul 01, 2016 03:36pm
Every one should be free to talk
Recommend
Jaat Jul 01, 2016 03:43pm
@Umar khan definitely you didn't read right
Recommend
M. ASIF Jul 01, 2016 03:44pm
It would be sensible to focus on subject you have studied and have its knowledge. Sometime success make people overconfident and lecture on matters their knowledge is zero. This is the case with Irfan. Success in films is a temporary phase may be tomorrow you will be forgotten but you are not qualified to speak on religious matters. Plz stop.
Recommend
Abdulla Hussain Jul 01, 2016 04:04pm
If he knew Islam & Islamic rites he would not be talking like that. His knowledge about Islam is limited 0.01% . He says Animals are slaughtered in Muharram whereas Animals are slaughtered in Eid al Adha (Bakra Eid). These filmi guys are commercial peoples living for money only.
Recommend
AP Jul 01, 2016 04:47pm
I guess he is trying to say something very positive, but before he opens his mouth he should go and research bit more about the religion.
Recommend
Ali Jul 01, 2016 04:47pm
@dp which part? Fasting is one of the fifth pillars of Islam. Thought being a muslim he would know that?!! And as already mentioned several times, the ritual of Qurbani has nothing to do with Muharram. Moreover, the meat is distributed to friends and relatives as well as the needy.
Recommend
ahaq Jul 01, 2016 04:49pm
I think Irfan has a point to make. The emphasis on the meaning of a ritual must not be lost. Good point
Recommend
Naeem Jul 01, 2016 04:54pm
Freedom of expression is right for everyone.. I do agree his some of the arguments but some of them are illogical. So Irfan sahb pay heed on your career..
Recommend
SidSingh Jul 01, 2016 05:38pm
All my friends are just rejecting his arguments and suggesting him to mind his own business. I wish someone please educate me a bit about where/how he is wrong by putting some facts. Qurbani is to sacrifice something dear to us and it may or may not be a goat. I find his arguments Logical and Sensible and he has all the rights to speak his heart irrespective of his religion. This is the need of the time to introspect our practices whether we are Hindu or Muslim or any. We should not be ignorant or close our eyes seeing the unjustifying things happening around. Extremism in religion is wrong and has bad consequences.
Recommend
Ashfaq Jul 01, 2016 05:46pm
Irrfan Khan is mostly right -- he got mixed up with Moharam and Haj -- but look at what he is trying to explain -- most of the rituals we do is without thinking and knowing the real reason behind them.
Recommend
Proud Indian Jul 01, 2016 06:19pm
@Umar khan read full comment. He did not ssaid Qurbani in Muharam. Here is the comment. Read it fully and tell me what is wrong in this comment. "Rather than fasting during Ramadan, people should self-introspect. Animals are being slaughtered in the name of qurbaani during Muharram [a Shia religious event]. We, Muslims, have made a mockery of Muharram. It is meant for mourning and what we do? Take out processions," he said.
Recommend
goutham Jul 01, 2016 06:35pm
Problem with religion is people become too focused on rituals and doing the steps exactly than on self introspection and personal growth. This is not a problem with just Islam but any religion. Let the man speak his mind for Gods sake!
Recommend
Ajay vikram Singh Jul 01, 2016 06:36pm
Lets avoid being sentimental ( un-islamic) and analyse his views rationally ( Ijtihad). isnt it true what he said? Religion is essentially not about "doing", but rather its about "being". There is a soul of every religious ritual and that esoteric aspect is the real objective. Ramzaan means the month of taking a pause, look inwards and introspect over your flaws and weaknesses and try removing them. Roza means, fasting from worldly affairs, food is just symbolic. Muhharam means time of mourning for your past mistakes, so that you dont repeat them in future. Qurbaani means giving up something you are attached to, as that reminds you of final and only attachment and that is to absolute truth - also means, God.
Recommend
Sami Jul 01, 2016 07:03pm
I think Irfan bhai started off in the right direction but, through ineleqouence , messed up his delivery. I think the idea of sacrifice should be expanded past just the sacrifice of animals, most of them bought a day or two earlier anyway. I think we need to start thinking of the poor, bad and some downright evil traits amongst us that we appear to be in love with. Why else would we hold on to them, repeat them often, and pass them down our generations. I hope we can take some time and reflect and commit to rid ourselves, and ultimately our society, one by one, each year, of traits that we hold on to so dearly, that ail our society, bring misery, backwardness, hurt, pain and distort and dilute the meaning of all the "good" we do, mostly in the name of rituals.
Recommend
Sourabh Jul 01, 2016 07:22pm
I think his comments have been taken out of context here. He DID NOT speak against Islam or any Islamic practice. Rather he was telling people to re-kindle the real spirit of these observances. And yes, he did not confuse ramzaan with muharram. He spoke first about ramzaan and then made an additional comment about muharram.
Recommend
WaheedNoor Jul 01, 2016 07:36pm
In India these clerics issued a fatwa against Muslim actresses (Shabana Azmi). Then they were critical of Sania Mirza for wearing short skirts while playing tennis. Now they are advising Irrfan to mind his career. Should they not follow their own advise and shut up in matters NOT relating to religion like sports and acting?
Recommend
Arif Jul 01, 2016 07:41pm
Irfan bhaijaan, Fasting helps to attain piety and teaches someone that if he can avoid a glass of water despite thirst, he could conquer a lot of other temptations if he wants to. As far as qurbani is concerned, you probably meant during the Hajj, why dont you see it from a different angle. The meat is distributed amongst millions of poor people who are surviving on bread and water on a daily basis. Both the above commands are from God, its not man made. However, i do agree, that people lack the knowledge and the essence/spirit behind a given ritual and take things for granted. There are also other rituals which are invented and have no connection with the real religion.
Recommend
Arsalan Jul 01, 2016 07:47pm
That's teaching Islam in India vs Pakistan, don't blame the actor, I blame the media that overblows his news and of course the 'institute' he works for called Bolly....
Recommend
Indian Jul 01, 2016 07:49pm
Why can't someone actually answer his question rather than criticising him for questioning.
Recommend
Abhishek Jul 01, 2016 08:01pm
Do not think he said anything wrong here. He is being criticized for no reason. In all religions, people practice rituals without having knowledge of it. Moreover, its his view. Accept it or ignore it. Simple
Recommend
SK Jul 01, 2016 08:21pm
Just because his views don't fall inline with yours doesn't mean that they do not have validity. Since when has religion become so weak that it cannot tolerate criticism.
Recommend
Masood Hussain Jul 01, 2016 08:27pm
It is heaps of wealth they make,turn them crazy. without doing any hard work,
Recommend
Tasaduq Ali Mir Jul 01, 2016 09:05pm
@Ajay vikram Singh Agree with you
Recommend
Vikas Gupta Jul 01, 2016 09:49pm
He is absolutely right, belonging to a particular region does not mean Anyone should give up common sense & logical thinking And asking appropriate questions,
Recommend
umair Jul 01, 2016 11:29pm
Irfan bhai only thinks of his movie promotion.
Recommend
Ajaya Dutt Jul 02, 2016 12:06am
Deep and honest thinking. Ritualistic Same'O Same'O will not understand it.
Recommend
umair Jul 02, 2016 12:27am
@Rashid Sultan No,it is his promotional right.
Recommend
faiz Jul 02, 2016 01:06am
His opinion and critics are all that matters but had he been a pakistani citizen things could go as far as ... but then he wouldn't dare I guess
Recommend
Reeba Jul 02, 2016 02:00am
Kudos to Irfan Khan who cares mor about the essence of the religion than blind rituals.
Recommend
Sachin Jul 02, 2016 02:29am
We need to be more open about criticism in our practices. Plenty of people criticize Hindu odd practices. Its ok.
Recommend
KN Jul 02, 2016 04:17am
Bravo Irfan Bhai. Standing up for your beliefs and not being scared into shutting up. Well done.
Recommend
Faisal Jul 02, 2016 05:54am
@Rashid Sultan Yes! It's his democratic right. And it's my democratic right to say that he's doing it only for publicity of his movie or just to please his movie's producers. And it's also our democratic right to refuse to watch his movie and tell our friends not to watch it.
Recommend
thoughtpurification. wordpress.com Jul 02, 2016 09:41am
@ahmed No body is perfect
Recommend
Akbar Safi Jul 02, 2016 04:34pm
Irfan...this is not a movie in which you would play any kind of role. Please don't mix up Islam and your Bollywood movie dialogues
Recommend
Sarwat Baig Jul 03, 2016 02:52am
Actors act as experts because we pay too much attention to them. If they don't want to be role models in real life then we should also restrict them to their reel lives.
Recommend
Tahir Usman Jul 03, 2016 05:02am
We must consider the cultural and religious sensitivities, when talking on religion. Otherwise, you may be trigger of religious riots. One can speak on religion, when one has very sound knowledge, and can express the difference of opinion in soft words and sublime way.
Recommend
Sardra Ehtesham Khan Jul 03, 2016 10:33am
@xpakistani not really actually we have lost the real meaning if qurbanl
Recommend
shami Jul 03, 2016 02:28pm
He dont even know that qurbani is done in the month of Hajj not Muharram and people donot just buy the animal and slaughter it they bring it a few days before, surve it to their best and then qurban it.
Recommend
Maghazi Jul 03, 2016 02:38pm
I respect his introspects in acting, (observed personally) not in Islam though. His criticism could have been taken if they were correct (or if he were a practicing Muslim) but here neither apply. And "Muslims not condemning"... please even Fox News has moved on from this these days. So no thank you and good day.
Recommend
Truth Jul 03, 2016 08:01pm
Some Bollywood actors should learn about their religion before talking about it. It becomes a micky.
Recommend
Dimple Khatri Jul 03, 2016 09:34pm
you are a real human being. I very much proud about your hamanity towards animals.Thanks...
Recommend
SidSingh Jul 04, 2016 09:56am
If you question the religious practices, People immediately get offended and instead countering on logic, they take it as Anti-Islamic act which is unfortunate. Religious reform is the need of the time and it applies to all the religions across globe.
Recommend
zakhta Jul 04, 2016 12:19pm
Too bad these people can go to such lengths just to publicize their movies by hurting the religious sentiments of a group. It's none of their business to discuss these things however he can choose not to practice these rituals by himself.
Recommend
Deepali Jul 04, 2016 03:43pm
@Ajay vikram Singh absolutely correct
Recommend
Shabana Jul 04, 2016 03:50pm
@WaheedNoor Yes. However the difference is that in context of India, most of these clerics in India have no significant standing. So honestly it doesn't matter what they say and sometimes, one or two media houses may cover their statements once or twice - but are seldom taken seriously. Bottomline is that Shabana Azmi is still acting and Sania Mirza is still wearing short skirts :)
Recommend
Vivek (Indore) Jul 04, 2016 06:26pm
I agree with everything he said
Recommend
Iqbal Ali Jul 05, 2016 06:52am
It a direct challenge to the intellect of guys like Maulana Abdul Wahid Khatri. They will definately respond back and save their territory.
Recommend